I read on and true. But you do get my jist ... besides, 410 bore and 28 gauge are more geared toward experienced shooters I would think. Get a kid a 20 and he/she will actually be able to lill something with it...or bust a few clays. As a father that went through this dilemma one will find their kids shooting a mighty 12 before long.... Not looking for an argument just trying to be helpful...
Experienced shooters 410 yes, 28ga no I don't agree but to each their own.
I guess it was different for me. I grew up in a house with a bunch of skeet and trap shooters and every gauge was available to me when the time came for me to start shooting in the mid 60's and what I was given was a Model 12 28ga which I still have to this day . I was 10 at the time and had a hard enough time shouldering that little 28 and could never handle a 20 at that time
I was never at a disadvantage with the 28 on the clays field or upland hunting and actually shot the small gauge better than most would a 12ga , even when I started shooting four gauges the 28ga would be my favorite and is to this day. Also the gauge I shot my best scores with
Any how my only concern here is can a 10 year old handle a 20ga when his dad indicated he cannot shoulder a light 20ga semi. I quote
He's only 10 so that would be too front heavy for him. I have a light 20g semi with 28" barrels and he can't mount it.
Some reading from chucky also which seems to indicate 20ga is fine IF the youth can handle it properly and i agree with his comment
I would estimate that a 20 gauge gun is the best starting point for about 90% of all beginning shotgun shooters over the age of 16.
If the youth cannot shoulder and handle it properly I can see a lot of frustration and scores as if he was started with a 410 which will quickly lead to lack of interest in shooting
Just my 2 cents
http://www.chuckhawks.com/first_shotguns.htm
Cheers