I have been looking into getting a newer hunting rifle for this year and really want a 45/70, I found a 45/70 marlin stainless steel guide gun with black walnut, but from different things I've read everybody online seems to say I want one with a JM stamp, are the stamped omes really that much better? Am I going to run into problems if I get a not JM one?
Marlin 45/70 need some help
- Thread starter Pozi4x4
- Start date
Bought one just before Christmas. I love it. Fit and finish I would say is on par with any other gun in that price range.
They did have issues post Remington take over but on all accounts the current production has most issues worked out.
The only issue I found was that there were sharp edges on the internal metal.
They did have issues post Remington take over but on all accounts the current production has most issues worked out.
The only issue I found was that there were sharp edges on the internal metal.
Wild_Thing
CGN Ultra frequent flyer
- Location
- In the thick of it!
JM stamp signifies one that was manufactured before Remington took over Marlin in 2007. Initially there were some issues. fit and finish, functionality, etc. Generally JM stamped rifles will sell for more because they are seen as better made. However my neighbour picked up an 1895 Classic late last year and it looked great. Works well from what I have heard.
In any case you would be well advised to physically, carefully inspect any Marlin prior to purchase for fit and finish and functionality.
stevey3737
Regular
- Location
- Southern Interior
I have a stainless remington marlin 45/70 guide gun and it is a fantastic rifle it cycles beautifully the fit and finish is as good as any i have seen its the same old people are sheep crap as always, the company messed up on some rifles on takeover, corrected it but will never live it down. the only thing i can suggest is actually handle rifle, cycle the action, look at the fit and finish and if its good for you buy it, you will love it. i do and so do a tonne of others
- Location
- In the shadows of the Rockies
Purchased new last summer. No issues. Very good fit and finish.
Might take into consideration the store's return policy. Some will allow a defective rifle to be returned for exchange. Or some will provide a full refund. Rather than dealing with the manufacturer.
Might take into consideration the store's return policy. Some will allow a defective rifle to be returned for exchange. Or some will provide a full refund. Rather than dealing with the manufacturer.
Trimmer 905
CGN Ultra frequent flyer
I bought a 1895 two years ago that looks perfect and works like a charm. Don't pay any attention to internet ax-grinders,they're like diapers---always on your a** and usually full of shyte. Like anything else,take a good look,first,but,new,they're rock solid rifles.
I’m glad to hear that you guys buying recent production Marlins are happy with the product and are enjoying them. I have a couple newer ones myself and they’re fine.
That said....... not everyone with a negetive review is a diaper wearing sheep, who’s just repeating internet rumors. Own more than one or two and you’ll find out really quick that they produced a lot of garbage over the past 10 years (not just the transition period).
A new Marlin will never have the same craftsmanship/feel as an older JM. You don’t have to agree, but it’s true.
That said....... not everyone with a negetive review is a diaper wearing sheep, who’s just repeating internet rumors. Own more than one or two and you’ll find out really quick that they produced a lot of garbage over the past 10 years (not just the transition period).
A new Marlin will never have the same craftsmanship/feel as an older JM. You don’t have to agree, but it’s true.
- Location
- West Central Alberta
The new Marlins are excellent quality but I'd go with a 1895 GBL instead of a guide gun.
GBL will give you a six round mag while the guide gun is only a four round mag.View attachment 151057
- Location
- In the shadows of the Rockies
I got mine new last summer on sale plus there was a $100 rebate offer in effect. My GBL was $675 total delivered to my door.
i have my guide gun, grey laminate and stainless, its my favourite gun in the safe... i had one not stamped and this one is, and honestly, aside from the stamp itself , i saw felt noticed zero difference at all, i load, point, squeeze, it goes boom, and the bears fall down!,
get one, you`ll love it!!,
get one, you`ll love it!!,
BrotherRockeye
CGN Ultra frequent flyer
- Location
- Rural Saskatchewan
you might wanna check out the Marlin Rant thread on the Marlin Owners site...
+1 to this ^^^
