Looks like mostly the issue is a "half #### notch" in the trigger assembly that fails and causes this. BUT that is with all types of shells. Your gun seems to not like the Challenger brand. Guys over at Mossberg Owners recommend taking the bolt apart and taking 1/2 coil and NO MORE off of the firing pin return spring to make the "balance" I mentioned earlier between the weight of the hammer spring and the weight of the firing pin return spring. Good time to thoroughly clean and de grease also. The Challengers will have Cheddite primers and they may be a little harder than the others. An over strong firing pin return spring mixed with a somewhat hard primer mixed with a cartridge with low rim thickness specs can all add up. Or it could one of each. Like I said we can work through it. BUT if it is new a warranty claim should be made. If you know anyone with a 88 to swap the bolts/trigger groups with that would be a good test too. I would assume a Mossberg 500 bolt would work also.
Darryl