MDI SLR receivers come loose.

HotSoup

CGN frequent flyer
EE Expired
Rating - 100%
19   0   0
Location
East
The retention bolt comes loose between 60-100 rounds every time. Double tapping seems to shake it loose even faster. Took out the build for the 3rd test run today, and had to re-tighten the bolt 3 times.

Ive always tightened it pretty snug by hand. Having to go tighter now. Even tighter and I know eventually itll just wear out the threads.

MDI needs to develop a better detent system for these receivers.
 
Last edited:
MDI recommended I put a washer under the bolt head and then re-tighten.

Not exactly an ideal solution but I'll give it a shot...

This is NOT a quality product folks. Poorly executed design IMO.

WAIT FOR THE MODERN SPORTER, IN MY HONEST OPINION.

The SLR is not well conceived or executed. I am not happy with this product.
 
Last edited:
MDI recommended I put a washer under the bolt head and then re-tighten.

Not exactly an ideal solution but I'll give it a shot...

This is NOT a quality product folks. Poorly executed design IMO.

WAIT FOR THE MODERN SPORTER, IN MY HONEST OPINION.

The SLR is not well conceived or executed. I am not happy with this product.

Agreed. It has a premium price and under delivers on product.
 
There's a reason bolts aren't used in modern semi-auto rifles for takedown components. When they are used that's why things like gas keys and buffer tubes are staked...

I mean, they could have used a spring detent ratchet thing for the screw or something... As nice as they look on the outside (I like the style) I'm really glad I waited it out....
 
Agreed. It has a premium price and under delivers on product.

I find mine of top quality with great fit and finish. I am not fond of the take down bolt however I seldom strip the receivers for cleaning. Never clean my AR’s, oil and go!

I would agree that it is a bit expensive tho, but that is the price to pay for NR semi autos in this country.
 
I find mine of top quality with great fit and finish. I am not fond of the take down bolt however I seldom strip the receivers for cleaning. Never clean my AR’s, oil and go!

I would agree that it is a bit expensive tho, but that is the price to pay for NR semi autos in this country.

I don't really agree that it's the price we pay for NR, if that was the case we wouldn't have the WK180-c for $1000. What you're paying a premium for is the top quality CNC machining and 7075 aluminum billet as well as a long list of other production expenses, unfortunately these don't seem to be living up to the top quality bit.
These are pretty much the same price as the ATRS receiver sets (even their restricted receiver set is almost $1000 and has been for years) and while I agree that they are expensive and it's a lot of money for a stripped receiver set I don't think they are overpriced or that we are being gouged, these are not and never were advertised as a budget or entry level product that everyone could afford. If someone wants budget and affordable they need to settle for something like the WK180-c and not a SLR or MS build.

It's hard not to compare them to a forged set but it's not fair to compare something that is a mass produced forging to a small run CNC process, CNC is going to cost more regardless of it's legal classification and anything made in Canada is going to cost more due to our high pay rates here.
Hard to produce a product for $500 when the labor costs are going to be $200 per unit since they still need to be paying a skilled tradesman to sit at the CNC machine for 2 hours while it carves out the receiver and then another well paid skilled worker does the finishing work and handling before it's sent off for coating or surface treatment. There's a lot of overhead for a shop in Canada as well, unless they are operating out of their home garage there are a lot of costs just having a space which I'm sure you can relate to with your own monthly bills for your home.


Would some kind of locking washer work? You know the kind that are slit (I can’t post pics right now I’m on my phone).
.

A split washer would probably gouge the aluminum receiver when you tighten it down, would probably hold but it will make a bit of a mess after you've tightened it a few times.
 
Last edited:
Repeated threading and unthreading of a steel bolt into an aluminum receiver - what could possibly go wrong?

I would rock set in a stud and then use a nylock nut - given there is room for the nut.

Sounds like a bit of an abortion.
 
I don't really agree that it's the price we pay for NR, if that was the case we wouldn't have the WK180-c for $1000. What you're paying a premium for is the top quality CNC machining and 7075 aluminum billet as well as a long list of other production expenses, unfortunately these don't seem to be living up to the top quality bit.
These are pretty much the same price as the ATRS receiver sets (even their restricted receiver set is almost $1000 and has been for years) and while I agree that they are expensive and it's a lot of money for a stripped receiver set I don't think they are overpriced or that we are being gouged, these are not and never were advertised as a budget or entry level product that everyone could afford. If someone wants budget and affordable they need to settle for something like the WK180-c and not a SLR or MS build.

It's hard not to compare them to a forged set but it's not fair to compare something that is a mass produced forging to a small run CNC process, CNC is going to cost more regardless of it's legal classification and anything made in Canada is going to cost more due to our high pay rates here.
Hard to produce a product for $500 when the labor costs are going to be $200 per unit since they still need to be paying a skilled tradesman to sit at the CNC machine for 2 hours while it carves out the receiver and then another well paid skilled worker does the finishing work and handling before it's sent off for coating or surface treatment. There's a lot of overhead for a shop in Canada as well, unless they are operating out of their home garage there are a lot of costs just having a space which I'm sure you can relate to with your own monthly bills for your home.


.

A split washer would probably gouge the aluminum receiver when you tighten it down, would probably hold but it will make a bit of a mess after you've tightened it a few times.

I will reiterate as I meant “this is the price we pay for NR AR type rifles” in Canada.
 
Dont buy an SLR folks.

Get a WK-180 instead, seriously.

Or wait for the Sporter

ATRS at least makes a quality product, not like the two goofballs who came out of nowhere with Maccabee Defense...
 
Dont buy an SLR folks.

Get a WK-180 instead, seriously.

Or wait for the Sporter

ATRS at least makes a quality product, not like the two goofballs who came out of nowhere with Maccabee Defense...

That's what I did. Cancelled and got the wk180c. Love it. Put your flame suit on and prepare to repel boarders with this thread. Interesting to note how the rifle upper and lower comes unthreaded. Is this common with other people?
 
That's what I did. Cancelled and got the wk180c. Love it. Put your flame suit on and prepare to repel boarders with this thread. Interesting to note how the rifle upper and lower comes unthreaded. Is this common with other people?

Only a handful of people actually have their SLRs. Maybe 120 or so. A lot of them arent even CGN posters. And i doubt enough have shot them enough to see. Shoot 500 rounds of 5.56 through it and come talk to me. Not .223, 5.56.
 
Only a handful of people actually have their SLRs. Maybe 120 or so. A lot of them arent even CGN posters. And i doubt enough have shot them enough to see. Shoot 500 rounds of 5.56 through it and come talk to me. Not .223, 5.56.

The forces on a rifle are not much different between 5.56 and 223. If it's happening with 5.56 you should see the same thing with 223.

As you say, most people probably don't have enough rounds through their rifle yet to have experienced this problem and anyone who discredits it without having rounds through their rifle would be wrong to do so.
 
Last edited:
Well all I know is that its a poorly conceived system. The forces exerted keep unscrewing the bolt, and tightening harder doesnt help. Im out of money to go back to testing with more ammo, but for now i put the minutest amount of loctite on the bolt. Hopefully that helps.
 
Well all I know is that its a poorly conceived system. The forces exerted keep unscrewing the bolt, and tightening harder doesnt help. Im out of money to go back to testing with more ammo, but for now i put the minutest amount of loctite on the bolt. Hopefully that helps.

Just use blue locktite, it won't ever harden up enough you shouldn't be able to get it out for cleaning.
What's the head used on the bolt? Hopefully not something that is going to get loose and strip out after a while.

From the sounds of it they could have skipped the bolt completely and just used some type of latch that stops the halves from sliding apart and would just be a push button to release it. Don't tell MDI, that's a patented idea and they should pay me for it when they change their design :p
 
Loctite will prevent the bolt from vibrating loose. Just sayin. Whine and ##### like a whiney ##### or come up with a solution to your problem.
 
Back
Top Bottom