If you could pick only one shotgun from this list.....

7

72mustang

CGN frequent flyer
Rating - 99%
97   1   0
Location
Canada's ocean playground
IF..... all these guns were in same condition
IF all these guns were the same price
IF all these guns were in the same finish
And IF all these guns fit ( shoulder) the same to you

.... and if you have experience with these in the past..... which would you choose over the other and why?

- Beretta 391 extrema 2
- browning Maxus
- Remington Vera Max
- Benelli Super Vinci ( yes, this is inertia vs the others are gas )

Flame awY...... lol
 
Beretta or Benelli depending on fit, and fit is the most important thing in shotgunning, for me I have shot both and would take the Benelli
 
As bunny said you have the 3 B’s of shotguns covered, shoulder them and see what “feels” the best. They will all shoot and will all get the job done and are all quality builds.

As a side note I’m an over under guy and can tell you I’ve shot better with a $1000 gun over a $4500 gun just do to fit and how it swung for me... Don’t skimp on chokes that’s the other difference maker, the Benelli Mobile chokes are amazing they pattern better than anything else I’ve used.
 
While I really like my Remington 1100, I was impressed with the performance of my Benelli M2 Tactical. I have a Benelli Ultralight in 28 ga on order.
I would probably go with the Benelli Super Vinci
 
out of your choice i will go with versa max. is one of the softest shooting guns and will cycle well with target and heavy loads. the super vinci being an interia gun im not a fan of, beretta 391a i think you should just step up to a A400 and the browning im not very fimiliar with.
 
Having had all but the Remington my vote goes toward the Beretta or Benelli. If the Beretta has K/O be aware that the LOP is longer than that without. I loved my Xtrema II, fit me fine but swinging it, it felt like I was swinging a 2x4. The Benelli is a slick rig with higher recoil. The Maxus I had had numerous parts breakages all of which were looked after and I'm sure I had a lemon as others I've hunted with love them with zero issues.

After playing with all these different shotguns I settled back on my old reliable Super Black Eagle.
 
I’m a big Benelli fan but dislike the Vinci.

Seen to many Versa Max issues wouldn’t even consider.

Preference to the Maxus but no issues with several Beretta 391’s I’ve owned both Sporting and Field just no experience with the Extrema.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom