Good on you and Craig Douglas.
I hope this new barrel shoots a lot better than the last one.
I would be interested to know.
It seems you've started a bit of a trend, or at the very least brought it to the surface. A few of the guys I know are also now claiming to be having accuracy issues with their S2 Weatherby's. I was curious to find out if it was just a certain cartridge, for the simple reason a lot of people purchase magnums they just aren't comfortable with shooting.
Turns out most of the rifles were from the batch of FLAME pattern, synthetic stock rifles that were sold at a huge discount a few years before Wholesale Sports went out of business.
KT, I know from your posts that your rifle isn't part of that batch.
I recently recycled a take off S2 barrel. It was chambered in 223rem and it was going onto a Remington Mod 7 action, so I had to cut off the thread tenon and rethread/cut new chamber for the 22-250 it was going to become.
I have no idea where the barrel came from. Whoever took it off, did a nice job with no marks, This was just a hunter profile barrel, so not a lot of room for playing around. This barrel was used because of its 1-9 twist rate and was picked up at a gunshow for $50. It also appeared to be used very little, if at all from new.
After threading etc and installation the Remington Mod 7 shoots the 22-250 with heavy bullets very well. The fellow using the rifle wants the heavier bullets for longer shots on coyotes when it's windy. Yes, he will settle on one bullet and use it for all conditions he's likely to run into.
The rifle was shooting 80 grain A max into less than a half moa, out to 300 yards, when I last spoke to him. He would certainly let me know if the rifle didn't shoot well.
Yeah, off topic, but I remember how much effort KT put into getting his 300WM to shoot well enough for his standards. Frankly I would have quit much sooner.
Ruger went through a stretch when their rifles were hit or miss for accuracy. From the rifles I've shot recently they seem to have fixed that problem.
It's possible Weatherby went through a similar issue.