What can 22 Rimfire be used for?

RSA1

Regular
EE Expired
Rating - 100%
126   0   0
Hi Fellow members,

Hoping you are fine. I am placing some notes here, rather than in the "Hunting" or "General discussion" section. Hope the Moderators feel it fits.

22 Short on “Big Game”?

These notes were written on 17 April 2020, hoping to bring interesting information/facts/fiction to fellow firearms enthusiasts/ legal firearms owners. It is not intended as advice, ethics for hunting or any illegal activity. If you have had enough Covid-19 news and facts and fiction, feel free to read on.

As a post graduate student in 1979, a friend gave me a copy of the book “Survival Guns”, written by Mel Tappan (1977). In it was written much about the usefulness of the 22LR cartridge. I did not own one, and living in a big city (Johannesburg) at the time, made it almost impossible to “prove” that I needed a “poacher’s rifle”. It was not until 1984 that I was able to buy a 22LR firearm. It was a beautiful BRNO Mod 11, which I bought with money from my Mother’s estate. It was a sad time, but the rifle kept her memory with me, reminding me of the great, but simple, caring and loving mother she was. Since then, I have always owned firearms chambered in 22LR, and try to keep adequate supplies. After all, Mel Tappan wrote that these cartridges will never lose their value, and could always be traded for other stuff.

So how useful is the 22LR? An extreme example comes to mind: In the book “The Sports Afield book of hunting and shooting records and facts”, 2015, on page 123, there is the story of a “girl” named Bella Twin from Lesser Slave Lake in Alberta, who shot a big grizzly with her 22LR rifle. One shot to the head brought the bear down. She shot it several more times in the head while it was down and “…jerking for a while”. This bear apparently was the “Boone and Crockett record and stood for many years”. Makes my mind boggle!

Now, a lesser known fact/story is a recording of court proceedings from a case of elephant poaching in Kenya, circa 1936. The story and details were published in the Man/Magnum magazine of January 2003, p61-63. It refers to a man that was tried in court for hunting elephant without a licence. He was arrested with five [5] sets of tusks. The accused claimed he did not have an “elephant rifle”, and swore that he had hunted the elephant with his 22Short (yes 22 SHORT!) rifle. The court asked Game Warden Thomas Carr Hartley to use the rifle and 22 Short ammunition to verify the story of the accused. Warden “Carr” shot a total of five (5) elephant as part of his “elephant control duties” to verify the accused’s story. This involved shooting for the top of the heart, as the elephant moved its front leg forward, aiming between the ribs. Shots to the top of the heart were more effective than shots lower in the heart. “On this evidence the accused was convicted of poaching. This was on record at the Kenya game department” (page 63).

So, there you have it; You forgot about Covid-19 for a few minutes.

Regards,
RSA1
 
Last edited:
people have used a .22 for more that it should have been still a common poacher/subsistence hunter caliber.

think about it for a minute in hard time(like the great depression) you are roaming around the woods with your .22 looking for small game to put some food on your table and a deer steps out are you going to try to take said deer. the cut shell thing comes from around the time of the great depression too turning birdshot into a field expedient slug to take a big game animal.

theirs some states that allow rimfire for deer down south BTW.
 
Hi antiqueguy,

Apparently (p63) "The elephant ran 150-200 yards and collapsed. Carr repeated this on four other elephant to prove the point".

This almost sounds like a politician talking.

Regards,
RSA1
 
Ah, the good old days when folks actually did factual research to get results, rather than sit behind a screen & rely on computer models or other crap.
Not to mention that back in those days, elephant & other heavy game were far less wary of people and wandered about in big herds during the daylight hours.
Elephant have long since then had to adapt to nocturnal foraging to try to stay ahead of human encroachment pressures to even exist these days.

I'll not ever put down the .22 rimfire as an effective fridge filler on any critter in my neck of the woods. Me 1st couple of deer fell to brain shots from my
Cooey model 39 using Dominion high speed shorts at close range. I've bonked most critters though, including pest black bear back in the days using .22 LR 40 gr solids.

No scars on me parts from those encounters happily enough.:d
 
Hi antiqueguy,

Apparently (p63) "The elephant ran 150-200 yards and collapsed. Carr repeated this on four other elephant to prove the point".

This almost sounds like a politician talking.

Regards,
RSA1

considering the aorta on an elephant is about the size of your wrist its not an easy shot.
 
I remember watching about 6 guys on TV with FN FALs dumping rounds into an elephant. It took about 20 rounds to put the thing down, I suppose placement counts.

in the ivory hunting days the top of the heart was the go to shot considering most of those guys used what ever they could get in a rifle. hitting the aorta will also get the bottom of the lungs on an elephant. most hunting is now done with a headshot on a charging elephant and a solid bullet doubt the old dangerous game guns with paper patch lead would do that unless we are talking 8 bore or larger rifles.

PS where's MR wolverine I think he has used an 8 bore a time or two.
 
Basically you can kill anything with the 22 rimfire in theory if one doesn t have any scruples and doesn t care if the animal languishes in agony for a long time before the wound becomes fatal and also depending on the animal if you want to take the chance on being killed by said amimal yourself before it dies.Killing faster and better is why weapons have evolved to what we have today and are continuing to evolve
 
Basically you can kill anything with the 22 rimfire in theory if one doesn t have any scruples and doesn t care if the animal languishes in agony for a long time before the wound becomes fatal and also depending on the animal if you want to take the chance on being killed by said amimal yourself before it dies.Killing faster and better is why weapons have evolved to what we have today and are continuing to evolve

I still do not see the need for something like a .300 win mag for deer that just adds to meat damage.
 
Last edited:
I remember watching about 6 guys on TV with FN FALs dumping rounds into an elephant. It took about 20 rounds to put the thing down, I suppose placement counts.

Hi Juster,

I have seen similar footage from culling operations in "Rhodesia", usually breeding herds (cows and young animals).

I also know that one of my former Nature Conservation Students reported buffalo being culled with FN FAL or South African R3 rifles (the student did not know the difference). These were buffalo in a holding boma (very strong wooden pole holding pen) in Natal Parks Board parks. The buffalo had tested positive for Bovine Tuberculosis, and had to be destroys. Shots were from above, multiple experienced shooters, head shots only, and the animals contained in the boma. Very humane, effective and economical. No need to use expensive drugs such as Scoline or M99.

RSA1
 
I take a lot of squirrels and rabbits with 22lr. I use CCI stingers 32gr HP they work great on small animals and with enough time out in the woods the freezer gets filled pretty quick. I feel squirrel is really over looked as an abundant natural food source, but they are actually pretty good if prepared properly. Mind you I’m not hunting city squirrels.
 
A good friend of mine was murdered with a 22. Ballistics say the first shot to her chest was fatal but she stood up after being shot. 6 more shots were fired. It may lack the knockdown factor but hopes and dreams cant fix bullet holes

Ive also read of small caliber and 22s being used to shoot kidneys of elephant and just waiting them out. Not sportsman like but we used to use sharp sticks to kill all game on earth
 
Just adds to the point that the shooter is more important than the rifle. You can be a skilled hunter and take down any game, without needing the latest and greatest magnums and ballistic tips
 
the comodo dragon has a toxic bite....it bites its prey then follows it and eats/kills it when its too sick to fight back....if you poop ( or something else toxic) on your ammo before shooting your 22lr or shorts....with a little patience you can probably take down anything....

not very ethical though.
 
the comodo dragon has a toxic bite....it bites its prey then follows it and eats/kills it when its too sick to fight back....if you poop ( or something else toxic) on your ammo before shooting your 22lr or shorts....with a little patience you can probably take down anything....

not very ethical though.

That's kind of a $#itty tactic. ;p
 
Back
Top Bottom