It's certainly not ideal as a person does want to be cognizant of the particulars of their load but I will stand by it not being a big deal to fire out a lost jag like that.(/quote)
Sure - I don't mean a big deal in the safety sense, but in the being a numb nut with guns sense.
I see no evidence of the rod having been attached.
Well I'm not sure how one would, seeing as the threaded end isn't visible. It's equally true there's no evidence of a rod NOT being attached. The threads aren't stripped or damaged by anything other than impact. They look like they were in fine shape before impact with the planet.
It would be very easy to not notice on ramming the load home that the jag is lost until the next shot.
Would it though? I guess if you were looking elsewhere, maybe, but I would think withdrawing a ram rod and not seeing the brass tip on it would stand out. More to the point is how on earth it would happen in any case. I don't see how a tip like that gets stuck onto a projectile. Certainly I've never felt any sticking or resistance when withdrawing a rod after ramming in any shot I've ever fired.
Threading the rod back on to pull it is unlikely to be successful.
Mmmm, this "friend of mine" did something dumb and ended up unscrewing a rod that was attached to a ball puller that was well screwed into a ball. It was no drama to re connect it and pull it out.
A whole rod is certainly a bad thing. It weighs many times the amount of any intended projectile and usually results in bruises, black eyes, broken stocks etc. though I've never heard of it damaging a barrel. Haven't seen anyone do it in person either so couldn't verify. A heavy metal range rod with a big ball handle is ideal as one should feel the weight or balance difference and the ball would interfere with the sight picture.
A hickory rod for my .54 Jaeger weighs in at 660 grains, 3x what a round ball does but only 50% more than a conical. Bad but not in the realm of crazy yet.
The rod for a CVA Optima OTOH comes in at a whopping 1/4 pound with the palm saver attached. Yikes. Indeed, firing a 1750 grain projectile would get one's attention.
Haven't been to a reenactment event in many years. Not using a rod makes safety sense but I wouldn't want to just be dumping in loose powder without a wad or regular swabbing. Uncompressed powder leaves a LOT of fouling from poor combustion and possibly embers as well.
Yup, that's exactly right. Video here shows it perfectly, firing loose dumped blanks followed by clearing the barrel of fouling and embers. I don't know what they do at tactical reenactments where ramrods aren't even allowed on the field and you're shooting more.