Trappers catch problem predators

Thomas D'Arcy McGee

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
Trappers catch problem predators

https://www.pentictonherald.ca/spare_news/article_08223475-c560-59eb-b3d5-06315014a222.html

CANADIAN PRESS
Miranda Leybourne, Local Journalism Initiative Reporter Brandon Sun 21 hrs ago

For many Manitobans, catching a glimpse of a grey wolf — with its long, bushy tail, thick coat that can range in colour from grey to solid white to brown or black, and its piercing yellow eyes — can be an exhilarating experience, albeit one best enjoyed from a distance.

But for some Manitoba cattle producers, especially those who make their living near Riding Mountain National Park, Duck Mountain Provincial Forest, Spruce Woods Provincial Park and other areas, wolves are a problem predator that need to be dealt with.

Currently, the province states that Manitoba’s wolf population sits at around 4,000, and appears to be stable, with an exception in Riding Mountain National Park, located 99 kilometres north of Brandon. There, the wolf population has been decreasing since the 1990s. As a result, wolf hunting has been curtailed around the national park.

In areas where wolf populations are stable, Manitoba Conservation allows trappers and hunters to target wolves, especially in areas where increased harvesting has potential to reduce conflict between wolves and agricultural interests.

Fewer than 40 wolves are killed by Manitoba hunters annually. The province says about 20 wolves on average that have killed livestock are trapped annually, and around 500 livestock have been killed or injured by wolves annually in the last five years.

The issue of wolves and other problem predators, such as foxes, coyotes and bears, came up at the last meeting of Manitoba Beef Producers in February, said Ray Bittner, who is a livestock lead with the group.

“The whole province has problems with coyotes and foxes. Certain … bush areas have problems with bears, and others … with wolves, so you have to deal with every area differently,” Bittner said.

When a producer loses an animal to a wolf or another predator, the first step is to contact crop insurance for compensation to replace the lost or injured animal.

If the problem persists, depending on their area, producers can reach out to the Manitoba Trappers Association to take part in the government of Manitoba’s predator removal program. The program helps with the removal of predators such as coyotes, wolves or foxes that have attacked livestock or that pose an increased risk to human safety. The program is not for general predator population reduction.

Claims under Manitoba’s wildlife damage compensation program indicate that wildlife damage averages about 20,000 acres annually, but can fluctuate greatly from year to year due to factors such as crop selection, weather conditions and food availability for wildlife. The program indicates there are about 1,900 claims for predator attacks on livestock in Manitoba annually.

For the past year, Bittner said, wolves were the biggest problem predator for producers, although there have been more issues with bears in forested and mountainous areas lately.

“I would say wolves have the greatest number,” he said. “It was mostly wolves for the second and third quarters [of the year].”

This marks a change from what the province of Manitoba has noticed in the past, stating that coyotes are currently identified as the predator responsible in about 75 per cent of insurance claims, with wolves coming in at 20 and black bears, cougars and foxes making up the remaining five per cent.

The Manitoba Trappers Association works closely with producers and on their land under the predator removal program, association president Gord Hannibal said.

“We’re allowed to basically take the wolf out of the system, and we have several different ways that we do that,” Hannibal said, adding that an exception is in place around the area of Riding Mountain National Park.

However, this is where a majority of wolf attacks on livestock occur, which Hannibal believes is due to the province’s bovine tuberculosis management program in Riding Mountain, which he said has greatly reduced the number of local elk wolves typically feed on.

Bovine tuberculosis is a contagious disease that affects cattle, bison, deer, elk, goats and other species, including humans.

According to a report from the Manitoba government, over the past 12 years, bovine tuberculosis has been found in 11 cattle herds, 22 elk and two white-tailed dear in Riding Mountain National Park.

Since there are no effective vaccines available for the disease, the province says the most effective control is to eliminate contact with infected livestock or wildlife and to destroy infected and exposed animals.

A task force for bovine tuberculosis was created in 2000, which funds and co-ordinates the bovine tuberculosis management program to eliminate the disease and includes representatives from Manitoba Conservation, Manitoba Agriculture, Food and Rural Initiatives, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency and Parks Canada. The Manitoba Cattle Producers Association and Manitoba Wildlife Federation provide consultation to the group.

As part of the program, all elk and deer hunters hunting in the Riding Mountain tuberculosis eradication area and the Duck Mountain tuberculosis surveillance area must submit the head, upper neck and lungs of harvested elk and deer to be tested for bovine tuberculosis.

As a preventative measure against the disease, the province is reducing and maintaining elk and deer numbers at a lower level, with attempts being made to target older male elk. As of 2019, federal government data showed that there were 1,216 elk in Riding Mountain at the time.

“We have a lot of wolves coming out of the park in search of food because the elk population is down about as low as it can possibly get. They have to come out to eat somewhere, so most of the time, it’s on somebody’s cattle ranch or farm,” Hannibal said.

The system needs to change to one that can zone in on the areas in the province where wolves are creating the most damage, he said.

Currently, about 50 trappers with the Manitoba Trappers Association actively help producers as part of the predator removal program. It’s a number that Hannibal would like to see increase.

“We have to educate our own trappers,” he said. “You can take a person that’s interested in hunting and train them to trap just as good as anybody else can.”

In addition to the program, the Manitoba government also recommends that producers monitor their livestock daily, maintain calving and lambing facilities near buildings where there is human activity, use pens to house livestock at night, alter the timing of calving and lambing seasons to reduce risks for young animals, avoid leaving livestock unattended in high-risk areas, store and dispose of after-birth and deadstock in a manner that prevents predators from accessing them, and more.

The province also cautions against removing predators where no livestock predation has occurred, since it will only allow for other predators to come into the area that may have a greater tendency to attack livestock.

Producers can also use electric fencing, guardian animals and other devices and repellents as interim solutions when faced with a problem predator.
 
Big guard dog is all well and good But it's a numbers game. 3 wolves vs the biggest baddest dog on the planet and the wolves would win everytime. They are smart and know how to work together. Watch them when they mess around with bears, Soon as the bear chases there's another one on his tail to bite him in the rear legs.
 
Is all "cuddly cute" story likely written by city person for city people to read. No mention of the elk or moose poaching going on in or around that Riding Mountain Park - no mention of First Nations having anything to do or say about it, no mention of the gov't sponsored "cull" of cervids in this area in winter of 2021/2022 - and so on. I live about 30 miles West of that park. There was wolves on this side of the Assiniboine River that I saw this past summer for first time since we have been here. Was at least one wolf shot in the hamlet of Shellmouth this summer - perhaps 15 miles from here.
 
Last edited:
Big guard dog is all well and good But it's a numbers game. 3 wolves vs the biggest baddest dog on the planet and the wolves would win everytime. They are smart and know how to work together. Watch them when they mess around with bears, Soon as the bear chases there's another one on his tail to bite him in the rear legs.

Agreed, i know some people in the Yukon, wolves were taking their chained up sled dogs right out of their yard.

Grizz
 
Big guard dog is all well and good But it's a numbers game. 3 wolves vs the biggest baddest dog on the planet and the wolves would win everytime. They are smart and know how to work together. Watch them when they mess around with bears, Soon as the bear chases there's another one on his tail to bite him in the rear legs.

Normally, Livestock Guardian Dogs work in groups not singles.

 
Big guard dog is all well and good But it's a numbers game. 3 wolves vs the biggest baddest dog on the planet and the wolves would win everytime. They are smart and know how to work together. Watch them when they mess around with bears, Soon as the bear chases there's another one on his tail to bite him in the rear legs.

Normally, Livestock Guardian Dogs work in groups not singles...


I'd never willingly put a single dog of any type up against a pack of coyotes, let alone a pack of wolves.

It would be great to hear from someone here who uses livestock guardian dogs in wolf country, I'm sure it's being done.
 
Do you think that Livestock Guardian Dogs would be an effective deterrent for the wolves ??

I live in an area of MB that has always been hit relatively hard by wolf predation. Many of the farmers have hundreds of cattle and in the summer months they are scattered on hundreds, sometimes thousands of acres of leased crown land. Dogs would be rather ineffective for this scenario. This is also the time when they lose quite a few cattle without their knowledge and don't receive compensation because it's hard to prove it was a predator kill. No snow for tracks and scavengers and rapid decomposition get rid of the evidence pretty quickly.
Up until the mid 90s, DNR used strychnine and cyanide quite effectively, but that's illegal now. Trapping/snaring problem wolves is easier said than done.
Moose numbers have also been on a steady decline due to overhunting,so the wolves in those areas are looking for prey elsewhere.
 
A picture sent to me by a correspondent - a "curio" - alleged to be home made dog collar for Ural Mountain dogs protecting sheep herds from wolves - those dogs and the wolves must REALLY mix it up!!!

9F57B8DA-3995-4466-9B76-C54B2FDB0449.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 9F57B8DA-3995-4466-9B76-C54B2FDB0449.jpg
    9F57B8DA-3995-4466-9B76-C54B2FDB0449.jpg
    78.6 KB · Views: 428
There was a cool documentary i saw on a sheep farm in Saskatchewan. Wolves were bad in the area. Something like over 7% of the herd lost to wolves yearly. The farmer then got two Anatolian Shepherd dogs with the spike collars and a Great Pyrenees. Those dogs would stay with the herd permanently and the Shepherds would hunt down any wolf if they showed up while the Pyrenees would stay put and watch the flock. I don't think they lost a sheep again. Amazing dedication
 
There was a cool documentary i saw on a sheep farm in Saskatchewan. Wolves were bad in the area. Something like over 7% of the herd lost to wolves yearly. The farmer then got two Anatolian Shepherd dogs with the spike collars and a Great Pyrenees. Those dogs would stay with the herd permanently and the Shepherds would hunt down any wolf if they showed up while the Pyrenees would stay put and watch the flock. I don't think they lost a sheep again. Amazing dedication

Do you have link to the documentary?
 
This one, right? Great Pyrenees, Anatolian Shepherds, and Kangals.



Sheep range differently from cattle though. You have to wonder if having any LGD around acts as a deterrent to predators (including wolves), just like having any anti-theft device works as a deterrent to thieves.
 
A male LGD will smash coyotes. From what I've seen, only the Kangal would have a chance against a wolf.
 
Oh yeah, forgot to say our government reduced the elk population in RMNP from 8000 to under 1200 by poisoning feed and paying people to shoot them out of helicopters. All meat was wasted. Such a shame! You can drive through the entire park and not see a single elk..

Not only are the elk numbers down, nothing was done to reduce the wolf populations at the same time. So the moose were wiped out too! Never underestimate the governments ability to screw things up!
 
Oh yeah, forgot to say our government reduced the elk population in RMNP from 8000 to under 1200 by poisoning feed and paying people to shoot them out of helicopters. All meat was wasted. Such a shame! You can drive through the entire park and not see a single elk..

Not only are the elk numbers down, nothing was done to reduce the wolf populations at the same time. So the moose were wiped out too! Never underestimate the governments ability to screw things up!

I can vouch for that. I grew up just on the outskirts of the park. Terrible what they did
 
Oh yeah, forgot to say our government reduced the elk population in RMNP from 8000 to under 1200 by poisoning feed and paying people to shoot them out of helicopters. All meat was wasted. Such a shame! You can drive through the entire park and not see a single elk..

Not only are the elk numbers down, nothing was done to reduce the wolf populations at the same time. So the moose were wiped out too! Never underestimate the governments ability to screw things up!

Yes. I am from the South Riding Mountain Park area too. Have friends there that lost a few cows and calves to wolves this year too. It’s ok for them to cull the elk herds and waist the meat but if you dare shot one or two they would lock you up and throw away the key. Friends of mine are also dealing with the TB Taskforce and well, dealing with Government is dealing with Government, we see how that’s going with our gun laws for example. The big city officials seem to think they know what’s best for the farmers.
 
Back
Top Bottom