What I look for:
Looks nice, shoots nice, makes me happy.
What I don’t want:
Ugly, doesn’t shoot, angers me.
Fortunately a lot of rifles work for me.
I've had a lot of hunting rifles over the years (certainly over the 100 mark). Mostly that's because I am a gun nut. I try one, or two per season, sometimes more if I go after more species. Oddly enough, I think that makes me less fussy. Accuracy for the cartridge and game, enough power to take it cleanly. Some I just take out because they have become like old friends, of a sort. - dan
What are the top 3
Top .......3 things you want in your hunting rifle
Bottom 3 .. I won't buy because
Stock , trigger, colour , weight , balance , barrel length , Mfg , history
What makes it work for you
^^^^^ bang on
1 - Carry/Packability
2 - Balance
3 - Weight
Personally I feel all three above are inherently connected as one regardless of whether it’s a LW Mtn/Backcountry or HB/CF type Long Range rig. It’s the three/one mains I consider when looking at or for a new rig.
Everything else like stock, trigger, load development/accuracy and can be addressed as you go.
There are three essentials to a hunting rifle; reliability, shootability, and accuracy. Take any one of those elements away and the rifle is not worth owning.
Reliability: simply put, it must feed, fire and eject with monotonous regularity. The sights, scope or iron, must stay attached to the rifle and stay zeroed.
Shootability: This comes down to fit, weight and balance, and they're not carved in stone. The factors that make a good thick cover deer rifle will be different from the requirements for a sheep rifle or a dangerous game rifle. A heavy-barrel, target stocked rifle will certainly kill a deer, but it's hardly the ideal configuration.
Accuracy: means more than tiny groups. A good rifle should put it's bullets into the same spot, hot, cold, wet, dry, clean, dirty, day after day. I don't care if a rifle shoots 1 1/2" groups, as long as those groups don't wander all over the paper if the stock gets wet or the barrel gets hot.