For the last 35 or so years I have hunted with the same small handful of guys. For the last 20 or so we have tended to go steeper and deeper. This has predominantly been backpack work, but some horse trips as well.
Get a few guys gathered around a backpack full of meat with a head perched on top and start guessing weights, its pretty easy to come to the conclusion that you are a group of bad mofos, and that pack weighs at least 135lbs. Or, conversely, that pack horse pannier CAN’T be more than 50 lbs, and that top pack is only 40 pounds, no problem.
Once we started carrying a scale in the trucks, or tucked in a pack box, it went from “that pack has to be at LEAST ###xlbs” to “It sure felt heavy by the time we crawled outta there. Lets hang it from the scale and see.”
The one constant that comes from weighing stuff that I’ve seen is that very few people have the ability to accurately judge weight (ESPECIALLY dead weight), and that people as a whole are very susceptible to pushing that number in the direction they want it to be while trying to guess said weight.
AND, people will argue a scale, because they “know” it weighed more than it had to. It felt SO much heavier than that….