Neck tension on 45 70 with cast bullets?

Kevin32

CGN Regular
Rating - 100%
4   0   0
My Lee expanders size the case to .453. which is quite a bit of neck tension with my cast .459 to .461 bullets. I feel like they could squeeze my bullets.

I've actually got the Lee neck collet die for the 45-70 but it is tricky to use and often buckles the cases. Plus I'd like full size resizing so my trapdoor rifle closes fully on them.

I'm looking at getting a different expander insert but is special order from the US.

Any other dies that give less neck tension or other suggestions?
 
My Lee expanders size the case to .453. which is quite a bit of neck tension with my cast .459 to .461 bullets. I feel like they could squeeze my bullets.

I've actually got the Lee neck collet die for the 45-70 but it is tricky to use and often buckles the cases. Plus I'd like full size resizing so my trapdoor rifle closes fully on them.

I'm looking at getting a different expander insert but is special order from the US.

Any other dies that give less neck tension or other suggestions?
Go to your local machine shop and have an expander made to fit your needs, or even a friend with a lathe.
 
.459 down to .453 is not neck tension, you are resizing the bullet when seating it which is horrible for accuracy. I'm surprised you're actually able to seat them like that. I imagine the resulting cases would have a pronounced bulge where the bullet sits. I would suggest ordering a set of RCBS cowboy 45-70 dies directly from the factory, they are set up with an M die type expander for cast bullets.
 
.459 down to .453 is not neck tension, you are resizing the bullet when seating it which is horrible for accuracy. I'm surprised you're actually able to seat them like that. I imagine the resulting cases would have a pronounced bulge where the bullet sits. I would suggest ordering a set of RCBS cowboy 45-70 dies directly from the factory, they are set up with an M die type expander for cast bullets.

Yes, I had a lot of misfires when I was new to it, being I was attempting to shoot extremely soft lead. Bullet exited without the powder igniting in my one rifle. Also seats them crooked a little, at least the .461 in the trapdoor. Using harder lead got rid of my misfires. Still suspect it's resizing a bit and causing accuracy issues. Yes has a noticeable bulge.

Trying to avoid track of the wolf. 60$ shipping for a 5$ part.

I heard the Lyman 45 70 M die brings them to .456. Wondering what other dies bring them to?
 
I shoot an original Connecticut Peabody in .45-70 using the Lee 405gr HB bullet cast 25-1 at .459-.60ish. I used Lee FL dies for several years with a .459 expander insert until I bought the aforementioned RCBS cowboy set. I prefer the latter. I get no shaving, no deformation, and easy concentric seating. The Lyman M die and RCBS cowboy sizer perform the same functions.

Your seating is resizing the bullet a lot and well beyond any acceptable measure. Pull a bullet with an inertial puller and measure it to find out. You should be using softer lead in a trapdoor not hard. It will help with obturation and should not affect misfires let alone cause your powder not to ignite. The wild differences in neck tension, bullet deformation, possible blow by from bulged cases will be the case of your lack of ignition. Using harder lead is treating the symptom not the cause.
 
Have you considered the Lee case flaring die to save the shaving of the bullet coating? It flares the case opening. Seating the bullet with a crimp bullet seating die crimps the flare down.
Buy a primer removing die and don't resize. Just crimp with a crimp bullet seating die.
If it isn't working without resizing buy some wads to keep the bullet high before seating and crimping.
 
I shoot an original Connecticut Peabody in .45-70 using the Lee 405gr HB bullet cast 25-1 at .459-.60ish. I used Lee FL dies for several years with a .459 expander insert until I bought the aforementioned RCBS cowboy set. I prefer the latter. I get no shaving, no deformation, and easy concentric seating. The Lyman M die and RCBS cowboy sizer perform the same functions.

Your seating is resizing the bullet a lot and well beyond any acceptable measure. Pull a bullet with an inertial puller and measure it to find out. You should be using softer lead in a trapdoor not hard. It will help with obturation and should not affect misfires let alone cause your powder not to ignite. The wild differences in neck tension, bullet deformation, possible blow by from bulged cases will be the case of your lack of ignition. Using harder lead is treating the symptom not the cause.
Thanks that's the info I was looking for!
Edit: of course both rcbs cowboy dies and Lyman m die seem entirely unavailable in Canada

My trapdoor is a bastard lol. It's got a marlin microgroove barrel on it which is why it likes .461 bullets.
 
Last edited:
Have you considered the Lee case flaring die to save the shaving of the bullet coating? It flares the case opening. Seating the bullet with a crimp bullet seating die crimps the flare down.
Buy a primer removing die and don't resize. Just crimp with a crimp bullet seating die.
If it isn't working without resizing buy some wads to keep the bullet high before seating and crimping.
Yes it's the Lee flaring die that expands the neck to .453. I believe the Lee full sized dies actually shrink the neck even further than so!
 
For my 45/70 rifles I purchased the ‘cowboy 3 dies sets’ knowing I would be shooting cast. For some like the 30/30Win where I already had a 2 die set I ordered just the ‘M’ die from Rusty Woods. You can play around and fudge load cast without the M die but bloopers and poor accuracy will haunt you. No shortcuts to success.
 
Agree with earlier posts, .453 is too small and will deform a cast bullet.

With soft lead bullets, .a neck .002" smaller than bullet diameter is lots. Crimp them.
 
Last edited:
found this pic of a RCBS cowboy expander , curious what the dimensions are for the mandrel portion?

1794614614675.png

The Lee expander is like this for 45/70 , again easy diy

1794615524814.png
 

Attachments

  • 1794615249222.png
    1794615249222.png
    16.1 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:
Well I don't have a lathe.
I'm going to be doing some measurements this weekend and estimate if the larger Lee expanders will produce off center or bulged cases.

Then I'll be ordering a bunch from track of the wolf. Shipping is 40USD or nearly 60CAD.

So if anybody else wants some once they're in Canada I can ship them to whoever wants for 30CAD recoup a bit of my shipping costs or pickup Squamish.
 
Boxhitch I have one of those Cowboy dies sets for 45-70. The lower part is about 0.4565" and the upper part ( for belling the case mouth ) is about .464.

I use a bunch of different custom ones made by Buffalo Arms as well.

Chris.
 
Thanks that's the info I was looking for!
Edit: of course both rcbs cowboy dies and Lyman m die seem entirely unavailable in Canada

My trapdoor is a bastard lol. It's got a marlin microgroove barrel on it which is why it likes .461 bullets.
Happy to help. At this point I order all my RCBS stuff directly from the factory in California. There is a lot of markup once it gets to dealers in this country which make it actually more expensive than paying in USD. Plus RCBS usually has free shipping. Just call them to order rather than doing it online.
 
Kevin32 one thing that might help your bulged cases is to back the sizing die off 1 or 2 turns. This will size the case a little less.
also wonder if this bulge is only seen with new brass, like I always get with fresh brass before fire forming, its going to show on one side just by nature of the brass, nothing to do with the die. Starline brass is forgiving this way, I partial resize just to get some neck back and leave the body alone. enough to hold the bullet and a crimp, brass lasts forever the less it is worked.
Kevin32, Not sure why you feel the need to full length resize ?
 
Back
Top Bottom