Identify yourself dang it!!!

I'm looking at the antlers and they sweep forward and branch up like a whitetail, do they not??? Maybe I'm nuts 🤪

Mule deer have different kinds of antlers and it's pretty common for them to have "short" sweeping forward antlers like that, much like whitetails there are lots of differences based on genetics. I see plenty of 3x3s that don't have the typical forked G2/3s. You're over thinking this.
 
Mule deer have different kinds of antlers and it's pretty common for them to have "short" sweeping forward antlers like that, much like whitetails there are lots of differences based on genetics. I see plenty of 3x3s that don't have the typical forked G2/3s. You're over thinking this.
Very good, I was just curious and obviously my ignorance when it comes to deer identification is showing 😆
 
If you shoot that deer and a C O checks you out, you best have a Mule Deer tag on it. It is 100% mule regardless of how the antlers look.
Now that we're discussing it just read that the antlers are the last distinguishing feature that you should use to identify what deer you have.

The first being the the metatarsal gland...
Whitetail
≤1" Small, low on leg
Hybrid
2–4" Intermediate position
Mule deer
4–6" Long, high on leg

Who knew... 😆

I guess the best part for me is, I'm so bad at hunting I've never had to worry about it because I haven't seen anything with antlers in person for years. 🤣
 
Good info! Thank you, everyone, for the clarification. Again, I'm not much of a hunter, so I just wanted to be sure.

My sister's young son just started hunting this year, and this camera is at the back of my property, surrounded by Crown land. I figured I'd point him in the right direction and hopefully help him have some success this season.

The real question is, if he's successful, do we make him drag it all the way back to the house, or do we fire up the tractor... hmm 🤔
 
Main thing for the average "non biologist guy" is look at the tail! We don't need a PhD to figure this stuff out guys! LOL
Cat
Always kinda bugged me that the ones with big white asses are NOT the ones called whitetail lol

(And yes I'm well aware of what a whitetail looks like when it's flagging.)
 
I used to have two racks that were cut at the skull cap, both fork horns.
One was a white tail and other a mule deer.
It used to be a fun game to take them to the range and have the " experts" try and guess which one was which.
The shape and coloring of the tail tells me which tag to put on a buck not the shape of the antlers, size of the ears or color.
Cat
 
Last edited:
Just out of curiosity, is the white rump and narrow black-tipped tail considered an absolutely definitive characteristic of a mule deer, or are there documented exceptions where a whitetail could display similar markings? I'm curious how reliable that characteristic is on its own.

I do understand that common sense and the actual regulations say to use multiple physical characteristics rather than relying on just one. What I find interesting is that the regulations also acknowledge that hybridization does occur and can make identification difficult. 🤣

One of those, it's your call buddy, good luck! 😆
 
Last edited:
I used to have two racks that were cut at the skull cap, both fork horns.
One was a white tail and other a mule deer.
It used to be a fun game to take them to the range and have the " experts try and guess which one was which.
The shape and coloring of tge tail tells me which tag to put on a buck not tge shape of the antlers, size of the ears or color.
Cat
Fork horns are not racks
 
Just out of curiosity, is the white rump and narrow black-tipped tail considered an absolutely definitive characteristic of a mule deer, or are there documented exceptions where a whitetail could display similar markings? I'm curious how reliable that characteristic is on its own.
For the hunter, that is the definitive identification as far as tagging goes. Regardless of what the antlers or ears look like.
I have never heard of a pure bred white tail having the rump like a mule deer or vice versa , and I doubt very much if you had your tag on a deer with a mule deer but if you woukd get an argument from any CO, even it it has occurred.
Cat
 
Back
Top Bottom