Identify yourself dang it!!!

For the hunter, that is the definitive identification as far as tagging goes. Regardless of what the antlers or ears look like.
I have never heard of a pure bred white tail having the rump like a mule deer or vice versa , and I doubt very much if you had your tag on a deer with a mule deer but if you woukd get an argument from any CO, even it it has occurred.
Cat
Thanks Cat, appreciate the knowledge. šŸ‘
 
Whitetail have a white belly, mulies dark. Usually easy to identify but, of course there are situations where the belly may not be visible, one reason to use multiple features for identification. A hybrid retains the white belly of a whitetail. It is my understanding that if you shout a hybrid, you can put either a whitetail tag or mulie tag on it. Not likely to see one of those though. On the topic of unusual animals, the strangest things I’ve see are a solid black bull elk and a 6 point COW elk (crossed the road in front of me)
 
Whitetail have a white belly, mulies dark. Usually easy to identify but, of course there are situations where the belly may not be visible, one reason to use multiple features for identification. A hybrid retains the white belly of a whitetail. It is my understanding that if you shout a hybrid, you can put either a whitetail tag or mulie tag on it. Not likely to see one of those though. On the topic of unusual animals, the strangest things I’ve see are a solid black bull elk and a 6 point COW elk (crossed the road in front of me)
I have seen antlered does but never an antlered cow elk.
Wouldn't matter to me as my licenses are for antlered or antlerless!😁
Cat
 
The interesting thing was that it a a 6x6 but the antlers were maybe 15-20ā€ long. That is what caught my attention and compelled me to look for nads as she went by at a walk about 30 yards. They could have been there snd I just didn’t see them but I don’t think so. Don’t recall ever seeing an antlered doe
 
You see muleys with whitetail-style racks pretty often. It's actually been a struggle for me to find a "normal" mule deer. After killing five in my career, I finally shot one this year that conformed to the standard, nothing big but he had two forks plus a brow tine on each side so it was a small accomplishment.
 
Just out of curiosity, is the white rump and narrow black-tipped tail considered an absolutely definitive characteristic of a mule deer, or are there documented exceptions where a whitetail could display similar markings? I'm curious how reliable that characteristic is on its own.

I do understand that common sense and the actual regulations say to use multiple physical characteristics rather than relying on just one. What I find interesting is that the regulations also acknowledge that hybridization does occur and can make identification difficult. 🤣

One of those, it's your call buddy, good luck! šŸ˜†

The tail shape is different in addition to the coloration - mule deer have a more ropey/cylindrical tail while whitetail are more of a wide and flat triangle shape.

1000035574.jpg


But if you're seeing a big white ass, and it's NOT a flagging whitetail, that's a pretty good indication its a mule deer.



Flagging WT for reference. If the tail isn't up, you typically don't see much white on em.
1000035575.jpg
 
Always kinda bugged me that the ones with big white asses are NOT the ones called whitetail lol

(And yes I'm well aware of what a whitetail looks like when it's flagging.)
+ not quite an antelope a s S but getting there, mule deer always looked like a 3 blade propeller when looking head on with the big ears
 
Even though that is definitely a Mule Deer be careful. The pics are not clear. He needs at least four one inch tines on at least one antler not including the brow tine to be legal. Depending on the pic he might have a fourth tine on one side but maybe not. In October he was for sure legal.
 
Even though that is definitely a Mule Deer be careful. The pics are not clear. He needs at least four one inch tines on at least one antler not including the brow tine to be legal. Depending on the pic he might have a fourth tine on one side but maybe not. In October he was for sure legal.
That’s a Legal antlered mule deer here in Alberta……

Silly point rules leave a lot of shot and left deer IMO
 
That’s a Legal antlered mule deer here in Alberta……

Silly point rules leave a lot of shot and left deer IMO

Antler restrictions are normally in place where the herd is managed for trophy quality or to help age class/structure. The goal of these "silly point rules" are to give smaller bucks a chance to make it past their 2nd year and prevent the orange army from shooting everything that moves.
 
Antler restrictions are normally in place where the herd is managed for trophy quality or to help age class/structure. The goal of these "silly point rules" are to give smaller bucks a chance to make it past their 2nd year and prevent the orange army from shooting everything that moves.
Good thing there’s no ā€œorange armyā€ here in Alberta.

Did you guys ever stop to ponder if those point rules are for herd structure or to make every hunter a possible violator and potential cash cow,, or worse yet to drive folks away from hunting……. Does it really help the herd, or quite the opposite?
 
Did you guys ever stop to ponder if those point rules are for herd structure or to make every hunter a possible violator and potential cash cow,, or worse yet to drive folks away from hunting……. Does it really help the herd, or quite the opposite?

lol really? "ever stop to ponder if laws are in place so that people break them?". Not everything is a conspiracy theory.

Point restrictions do work when implemented correctly. If a hunter cannot discern how many points an animal has or whether it fits the legal requirement and they shoot anyway, it's completely on them. I've hunted plenty of Provinces and States, some with and without antler restriction, and can most certainly say that from what I've observed, units/zones with restrictions have a positive impact on the quality of bucks/bulls.
 
Point restrictions do work when implemented correctly.

Sometimes.
And at other times they can and do have a deleterious effect.

Couple cases in point:

The Kechika system went to 6 point bull elk decades ago.
Today you are damn hard pressed to find a breeder bull bigger than a large 5 point.

Same has happened in numerous jurisdictions I hunt with mulies, with the breeding bucks predominantly large 3 or even 2 points.

Genetic selection in action.

I am firmly against this style of "management" as a consequence.
 
Back
Top Bottom