Morpheus32, what a grunt will tell a superior officer, or someone who could intern tell a superior officer, and the true reality are often two separate things. It's like when your CO tells you to "speak freely." Once in a blue moon a really good CO means what he says and will not hold anything against you, but most of the time it's an invitation to your own funeral. So you blow the proper sunshine up his a** and move on, just to get him out of your hair. Grunts know that most officers are just there to make grade and move on. There is little love between the two of them, and no real reason to help one another more than enough to grease the wheels between the two, and try and make the team work. Point being; unless you're one of the "grunts" then you will most likely never really know what they really think. You only know what they tell you, and 9 times out of 10 they are going to tell you what they think you want to hear.
As I stated earlier, I'm glad your experience with the AR was a good one, but nobody is going to tell me that .223 is a war round, even at 77grns, or that the Stoner gas system is anything more than a joke. I respect your service Morpheus32, and am happy for your safe return, but I think we should just agree to disagree here. Yes, the AR will work, but in a pinch, a Rugar 10/22 will kill, and if that's all your given, believe me, you will be motivated enough to make it do pretty good. It's your life that's on the line after all. You could be given McGuiver stuff (Bubble Gum Wrapper, and a Paper Clip) and you would figure out some way to turn it into a weapon and then use it to save your life. I dislike the AR and especially the .223. There are many others out there that agree with that also. Many others who have used said tools in combat. What irks me the most is that defenders of the system always seem to point out that "it works" or "it's technically" or any number of examples that conveniently avoid the basic physics of "bigger is universally deadlier" when referring to impact weapons. It feels like they are towing some company line, or trying to make grade by jacking up their superiors rehetoric. It may "technically" and it may "work" but compared to what? Back in the caveman days as an example: "Rock work good to kill enemy, Bigger rock work better!" Both will "work" but which one is the "Best?" That is my issue at hand in this discussion at any rate.
Most of the guys have never been given anything else to us, so how would they know if it "worked"? Maybe it sucks but they wouldn't know any better? The problem is; until you give one guy in a squad an AR to use and another a M-14, let them use them for 2 weeks in theater, and then let them come back as a unit to decide which one they all want to use (being given one choice mind you) it gets pretty moot.
I don't mean to jump off in your rear with this Morpheus32, as I said, I truly appreciate your service, but this is starting to get to the level of patronization. Lets just let this aspect of it go, eh?
P.S. As far as who my friend is, well, the truth of the matter is; this is an open chat board on the internet, and I don't know who you are other than who you say you are. I know you as Morpheus32, and I hope you will understand that I am not interested in getting my friend in any trouble, or providing his name, unit and location in an environment where anyone could obtain, and possible use said information. You can take my relay about what he said at face value, or discard it as BS, but I'm not going to just give out that information to someone I don't really know, or risk his safety. I will tell you this; he is real, he is my friend, he has a family, I have no reason to believe that he would lie to me, he is a good man who slings a rifle, and patrols with his men--signs up on the board for patrol rotation, just like any other grunt--and is one damned fine NCO, and he is currently in harms way. He has experience with multiple weapons (he's been in a long time, and we are shooting buddies) and knows what he is talking about IMO. Take that for what you will. I simply can not provide you with more than that, so if that makes me a liar...then I've been called worse in my lifetime; I can live with it.