It makes a couple of inches difference with a 7mmremmag.Seeing as how the deer was hit in the spine,a couple of inches difference could have resulted in either a clean miss,or a high lung shot.The largest difference however,is that the hunter may not have felt capable of consistent shot placement at 260 yards.The fact that the person lied about the distance gives me the impression that he wanted the shooter to take a shot that he might not have taken if he knew the actual distance.I don't agree with lying to give someone a false confidence.
Well...
First off a 260 yard shot from an awkward field position is not a simple shot for anybody.....The shooter was a good shot in his day, but being 90 years old and having a heart condition complicates matters somewhat. The shooting skills are there, but the old boy physically needed to be as calm as possible for the shot. I have known the old boy and his son for a bit over 25 years. I based my unconventional call both on that history and the field conditions.
I suspected he would shoot high because a small deer, standing in fairly tall grass, in an open field, looks so much further away than it actually is. The natural instinct is to lift the cross hairs....Especially given the tall grass.
I had a trajectory table taped to the side of his stock and he shoots enough to know the rifle impacts a bit high from 100-200 yards (the 250yd zero was his selection). At the shot I cautioned him to keep his cross hairs down on the body. Given the yardage corrections had been followed the bullet should have impacted 2-3" low of the intended POA...Exactly what I wanted.
After the deer was down, dressed, and in the truck the old boy confessed that despite my advice he couldn't help himself and raised the crosshairs.......I laughed and told him the actual distance. While we all had a good laugh he mentioned that it was all he could do not to put the hairs on the deer's back "and let her drop in".....
I appreciate you might not be comfortable with the ethics of the shot, but that shot marked the end of hunting for the old boy. Though we weren't sure at the time he and the rest of us could tell the physical exertion was becoming too much....We were right.
A nice shot, pictures, and a great memory with his son and a long time friend marked the end of his many years in the field...What more could a guy ask for?
Between the three of us we have never lost an animal. This was not going to be the first.