Like you I shot some semi pistol first before trying my first "odd looking" revolver. I thought they would front heavy and awkward to hold. But after shooting two cyliders worth of .38Spl through a Model 19 I was totally hooked on revolvers. If you had the same experience then by all means get a 686. They are a fine gun that will be a good cornerstone for your handgun collection.
But as a second handgun I would strongly recomend a .22 in either revolver or semi. First of all they are far, far cheaper to shoot. Secondly they really help work you past any bad flinching issues and help you work on achieving a nice smooth trigger pull and proper follow through. Shooting .22 was by far the best thing I did to aid in my accuracy and consistency.
Also .45 is far more costly to shoot unless you're already into reloading. And in that case it is still more costly but not by that much. To keep the costs lower you should stick with 9mm or .40 at the most for a semi pistol. So again that 1911 would not be a great first gun... along with the fact that chrome guns don't do it for me either so I also think it's totally fugly.... but that's a personal thing so if you do like shiney mirror like guns then satisfy yourself. Still, I think there's far better first gun options for all these reasons.
In fact I would suggest you keep an open mind and shop for 3 guns at the same time and buy whichever first comes up at a good price as your first gun. These options would be the 686 you already know you like, a nice .22 like a Ruger or a Buckmark and whichever 9mm you take a fancy to. Buy the first then save up for the next and the one after. And if you find you have a taste for 1911's in .45 then that could be your fourth gun. Or maybe that single action cowboy style if you get to try one and like it.
The message here is that very few folks are happy with only one handgun. There's no "do it all" handgun out there if you're doing this as a hobby and enjoy more than one aspect of handgunning. So plan on at least a modest collection and don't be afraid to buy the first good deal on one of the foundations for your eventual collection be it a .22, the 686 or a nice 9mm. But if you get one of the center fire guns as your first the .22 really should be the second one you buy.