Dare i compare????

[TheManInBlack]

Alright guys with them both being now available in canada here we go.


Robinson XCR

OR

FN Scar

Why do you think the rifle you chose is the best

 

[MosinNagantM44]

omg not again

 

[alexD92]

SCAR, lots of research and field testing.

 

[hbean]

Scar of course, anything that cost as much as SA rifle must be of the same quality right?

 

[blaxsun]

XCR baiting...

 

[shatthatkilledelvis]

XCR - Cause the stock on the SCAR looks like some POS tail fin that fell off a leprosy infested dolphin.

 

[mrsmitty]

XCR
pros
-non reciprocating charging handle
-better selector (opinion)
-better bolt release
-more affordable
-already available caliber change choices (6.8 and 7.62x39)
-non restricted

cons
-lack of extensive testing due to being a small company compared to a manufacturing Giant like FN
-Some QA issues

FN SCAR
pros
-extensive testing
-FN reliability
-Cold hammer forged barrel
-Use by Socom

cons
-price
-crappy stock (could say XCR stock is crap too but can be replaced with AR type stocks)
-reciprocating charging handle

Hard to say which one I like better. Will have to wait till I get my SCAR then I can compare first hand. Feel free to suggest to adding more pros or cons for either.

 

[richi]

So who here in Canada is selling the SCAR? price?

 

[mrsmitty]

Questar is preordering them. 3499 I do believe.

 

[oenone]

Questar is preordering them.

Pre ordering is not equal to them being available.

 

[frenchyguy]

Pre ordering is not equal to them being available.

exactly! i cant believe that someone would drop that much cash on a scar, when the xcr is as much rifle for so much less. but then again to each their own.. damn if i could afford it i would buy a case of scar's just because i could.. heheh

 

[F22_RaptoR]

Wow, for 3500 bucks, thats actually not too bad compared to what most guns in that "class" would cost.