S&W model 18 and HY Hunter 44 mag

[piper394]

An old friend showed me a couple of revolvers he wants to sell. A S&W model 18 (22 lr) prohib with a four inch barrel and an old HY Hunter 44 magnum , a SAA clone. The 44 is mechanically fine but shows external wear and the S&W is in really nice shape having fired under 1000 rounds.
Any ideas of value on these?

 

[JB]

An old friend showed me a couple of revolvers he wants to sell. A S&W model 18 (22 lr) prohib with a four inch barrel and an old HY Hunter 44 magnum , a SAA clone. The 44 is mechanically fine but shows external wear and the S&W is in really nice shape having fired under 1000 rounds.
Any ideas of value on these?

unless you are 12-6 you cant have the S&W model 18 (22 lr) prohib with a four inch barrel.So that leave you with the old HY Hunter 44 magnum

 

[piper394]

I am 12-6, so no problem there.

 

[rfo1]

If the Model 18 is all original and in good shape it should be worth $350.00 +. If he has the original box and manual maybe $25.00 more.