Meese Rancher, I personally prefer the ergonomics of a pistol grip stock over anything else, My Supernova tactical has one very similar to the Factory Rem one and it is perfect for me. Nice comfortable cheek weld and it puts the sights at the perfect level. Are you a bigger guy? I ask because the ATI stocks use a rather small pistol grip. My benelli and looks like that Remington stock too both use a larger SAW style grip that is more comfortable for me, Just more there to grasp. That being said I would still buy the ATI for another shotgun. For the price, both ATI stocks I've owned have been respectable quality, not top notch but they fit good and match the receiver well, so they get my vote. Have fun and let us know how it works out.