Accuracy is important, but if that's *all* you got to brag about in a hunting rifle, I suggest you stay close to the truck.
So here's another 'isolated' Ruger anecdote:
When I was 14 I went hunting with my dad. It was the first time I was allowed to carry the gun. Dad was busy with work and stayed in the truck to do some paperwork, but told me to go down this little draw, creep up to an aspen stand, and there should be a deer there. He was right. It was a decent 3 pt mulie; nice and legal. It saw me before I saw it, and when I did see it, it was staring right at me, only about 75 yards away. I was holding a Ruger Ultralite in .250-3000. Because of my inexperience I didn't yet have a shell in the chamber, so I
slowly worked the action trying not to scare the deer. The action jammed up. I tried to clear it, and that took a couple minutes. While I was fiddling with the action the deer walked off, up the other side of the draw, into some spruce jungle and was gone.
That was my first experience with ruger, but not my last. I've had other issues with Ruger. But I have killed a few deer with them as well. I've lost deer when holding a Ruger in my hands, and I can say that those losses happened simply because I was holding a Ruger. The .250-3000, .243 int'l, a .308 ultralite, a 7RM MkII, and a .338 are the Rugers I've had experience with. I've killed deer with each [not the .338], but I've lost deer with each [jams, FTF]. [not the .338, but it still had issues. Was never reliable enough to take hunting]
I've killed 7 deer in 2 seasons with my Tikka. Never had a problem. To me that is reliable. I know people don't like tikka because of the polymer mag and trigger guard, the plastic stock [mine's a hunter and has decent wood, so that's N/A] and the recoil lug. I've heard complaints about the bolt shroud as well. In the past 2.5 years, 7 deer, innumerable trips to the range, very hot handloads, and countless miles walked while carrying it, if it had given me issues, I'd get rid of it. But in my experience the Tikka's polymer mag, etc, hasn't held me back. Hasn't given me any issues. It
has given me reliable feeding, no jams, very good [outstanding] accuracy, and hits what I aim at. I'd buy another one with no qualms at all. Maybe in 300WSM [since wsm's are being bashed in another thread]. I don't think Ruger makes a terrible product, but I think that the Rugers are more tempermental and more prone to issues unless a lot of fiddling and after-market work is done. My Tikka has a user adjustable trigger, I like the wood stock, and I don't have to wonder when I buy one if the accuracy will be up to par. I can trust that it will be. And I'll have no fear about taking it far, far, far from the truck.