Keeping one, sellign the other, help decide

[brit84]

Im going cut loose one of my 357s and im not sure which since I like them both.

one is my s&w 586 the other is my s&w model 28.

I just dont need both and bought them both because i wanted to try the two.

Now I know the model 28 is better for magnums all the time, but Im usually just using 38sp and +p.

The 28 fill my hand a little more also, but I could just get some nice grips to replace the rubber ones.

What would you do? keeping both not an option!

 

[gnmontey]

Sell both, and get a 19

 

[tobin]

I prefer either the L or K frame's to the N frame. If you are shooting a lot of magnums, the L frame should be fine.

 

[brit84]

thanks, think im throwing the 28 up for sale

 

[Master-G]

thanks, think im throwing the 28 up for sale

Yeah, I'd agree. I've got a 686 and Model 28 and while I like the character of the Model 28, the L frame is a better pure shooter.

 

[COREY]

I had a 28; the only reason I got rid of it was that I found a 27 in good shape for a good price. I have shot the 686 bfore and I still like the 28 better. If the 586 fits you better, I see no reason to keep the 28 over it though.

 

[NAA]

I prefer either the L or K frame's to the N frame. If you are shooting a lot of magnums, the L frame should be fine.

+1

In a .357 I prefer the L or K over the N frame, too.

NAA.

 

[NAA]

Sell both, and get a 19

But only if it can be a 4" Model 19, though....

NAA.