You need to figure out what you want in a rifle. Ask yourself these questions...
1. Synthetic or Wood
2. Stainless or Blued
3. Detacheable magazine or Internal magazine
4. Is weight a factor
5. Does push feed or Controlled feed a factor.
Once you have answered those questions to yourself, you can pinpoint more precisely what you are looking for, and then pretty much answer the question for yourself.
For myself personally, I was looking for my Moose and Deer rifle to be...
1. Synthetic stock
2. Stainless Steel barrel
3. Detacheable magazine
4. Lightwieght
5. A common calibre that is easy to find anywere and does'nt cost a fortune to buy a box.
6. Nice, light trigger pull ( Tikka is adjustable )
Basically, what I look for in my ultimate hunting rifle is something that is very durable, weather resistant, light to carry, and I like a detacheable magazine so I can quickly jump out of the truck or off of a ATV and slam in a magazine and be ready to Rock N Roll if I see a Moose crossing a trail or a logging road that I am driving down. It also nice to know that my rifle can consistantly hit a Apple sized target from 200 yards away.
After I determined what I was looking for, I narrowed my rifle down to either a Remington mod 700 SPS DM, a Savage Weather Warrior, a Weatherby Vanguard, or a Tikka T3 Lite Stainless.
These models all had what I wanted, but I ended up choosing a Tikka T3 Lite Stainless Steel in 30/06. It cost the most out of the rifles that I listed, but it is the lightest, and the most accurate, and has the best reputation. You won't find too many Tikka owners out there that regret buying a Tikka. You can't say that about some of the others though.
I have a Burris Fullfield II 3x9x40 scope with butler creek flip up covers, and together, I have a really nice, light, bad weather rig that is more accurate than alot of other brands heavy barrel models.
I have owned alot of different rifles for Moose and Deer, and I can honestly say that for my current needs, my Tikka is by far the best rifle I have ever had for hunting. If I were to buy another rifle and I had a $1500 limit for rifle and scope, I would buy the exact setup that I have now, Without a doubt about it.
Here is what I bought. Tikka T3 Lite Stainless in 30/06 with Burris Fullfield II 3x9x40 Total price brand new out door is well under $1500.