Attention Winchester Collectors

browningsteve

New member
EE Expired
Rating - 100%
14   0   0
Location
Ottawa Area
I am looking to find out the value of my Winchester 1873 .44 WCF (44-40). Here are a few pics. From what I can gather from some internet research it is a third edition sporting rifle and I put the condition of the blueing at 85% and the condition of the wood stock at 90%. I would appreciate any imformation anyone could give me.

1873_6.jpg

1873_7.jpg

1873_5.jpg

1873_4.jpg

1873_3.jpg

1873_2.jpg

1873_1.jpg
 
it's worthless. It would make a nice anchor. Out of the goodness of my heart, I'll giver you $25 (oh, what the heck, I'm super generous today, make it $26), and I'll even pay the shipping.
 
looks like the original blue,case harding on hammer is like new ,this is a 98% condition gun and in a wanted caliber $3000+ ,very ,very nice
 
I don't know, the blueing looks like it could be an old reblue, certainly if it is a reblue job, it was done long ago, as the wear pattern around the sharp edges indicates age. Otherwise it looks to be in pretty good condition, I wonder what the inside of that barrel looks like?
 
Far from an expert, but if the bore looks as good that little part of the chamber I can see in the one pic. I'd get a serious evaluation of that rifle before putting it up for sale. That blue could be an old refinish, who knows? But I don't think that would be too detrimental to it's value. I've seen less, with an asking price of higher than $3000 for one of those. That is definitely a nice looking period rifle. How is the conditions of the stampings?
 
Last edited:
Far from a 98% gun, but that is certainly a very, very nice 73. You are lucky to have found one in that condition. The bluing appears to be original (especially given the case left in the hammer and lever) and there does not seem to be any dishing around the screws, but it is still hard to judge from pictures. As the others noted, don't be in a great hurry to sell until you know what you need to know.
Matt
 
I don`t know about the blueing it looks original to me be I am no expert. If it is a reblue it was a great job! The bore is good and the stamping are very clear.
 
I don`t know about the blueing it looks original to me be I am no expert. If it is a reblue it was a great job! The bore is good and the stamping are very clear.

All the more reason to have a competent individual evaluated this rifle. Lots of knowledge here, but get it to someone who can physically check it out & I wouldn't be in too big a rush to sell it, if that's what you intend to do. Just my 2 cents...
 
Far from a 98% gun, but that is certainly a very, very nice 73. You are lucky to have found one in that condition. The bluing appears to be original (especially given the case left in the hammer and lever) and there does not seem to be any dishing around the screws, but it is still hard to judge from pictures. As the others noted, don't be in a great hurry to sell until you know what you need to know.
Matt
howmuch % would you give this 73 ,? its one of the best I've seen around lately, I saw 73's sell here for $4750 and not as nice as this one
 
Hi bob,
That is a good question which only a hands on inspection under proper light will tell and even then two different people will have three different answers. The whole subject of grading the old firearms is a very subjective process, and that is one of the reasons I try to stay away from such specifics on here, including the what is it worth question. It is so hard to tell from pics sometimes and I don't want to tell someone they have a $5000 dollar gun, or for example, if it is only worth half that, or that a gun is 95% but then have the owner find out when properly looked at that is is rather an 80 or 85% gun. That is why I try to only offer advice when I am pretty certain I can provide something close to the right answer. All that said, this is indeed a very nice 73, but given what I recall from the photos last night (I am using my iPhone right now and don't want to base my opinion on photos from a phone!) I was thinking it would likely fall somewhere between 80 to 90%. Though it is of high condition, I recall seeing a fair amount of thinning on the receiver in places,etc. To be 98% the gun would have to be almost new with maybe the exception of a scratch or two. I am not taking anything away from such a nice example, nor anyone else's opinion, just basing my opinion (and that is all it is until it can be looked at properly) on what i could tell in a limited way from the pics, and that is why I avoided putting a price and a rating of condition on it to start with. Again this is all very subjective, and as others have noted, the owner should gets a hands on with the gun. It sure is a keeper. Good luck with it!
Matt
 
Hi bob,
That is a good question which only a hands on inspection under proper light will tell and even then two different people will have three different answers. The whole subject of grading the old firearms is a very subjective process, and that is one of the reasons I try to stay away from such specifics on here, including the what is it worth question. It is so hard to tell from pics sometimes and I don't want to tell someone they have a $5000 dollar gun, or for example, if it is only worth half that, or that a gun is 95% but then have the owner find out when properly looked at that is is rather an 80 or 85% gun. That is why I try to only offer advice when I am pretty certain I can provide something close to the right answer. All that said, this is indeed a very nice 73, but given what I recall from the photos last night (I am using my iPhone right now and don't want to base my opinion on photos from a phone!) I was thinking it would likely fall somewhere between 80 to 90%. Though it is of high condition, I recall seeing a fair amount of thinning on the receiver in places,etc. To be 98% the gun would have to be almost new with maybe the exception of a scratch or two. I am not taking anything away from such a nice example, nor anyone else's opinion, just basing my opinion (and that is all it is until it can be looked at properly) on what i could tell in a limited way from the pics, and that is why I avoided putting a price and a rating of condition on it to start with. Again this is all very subjective, and as others have noted, the owner should gets a hands on with the gun. It sure is a keeper. Good luck with it!
Matt
Matt ,thanks for the reply,and I agree that grading antiques can be subjective, BrowningSteve again superb 73 ,
best of luck
 
The best pictures are taken outdoors with natural light, no flash, out of the sun and on an overcast day.

When using a flash indoors it can make a object look totally different than what you see on a hands on inspection.

Very nice '73.
 
Back
Top Bottom