Why
But I have already TRIED painting myself blue and welcoming the solstice at moonrise, blowing a tribute through my Canadian issue funnel...
Seriously, I even own Stratton's books, and the Holy Grail of The Lee Enfield Story (2nd), AND I KNOW HOW TO WRAP A PULL-THROUGH!!
Why the Heck can't I figure this out???
Because you didn't have an old Sergeant-Major who was a former Instructor at the School of Musketry in Hythe, England, standing behind you ready to plant his size 11 boot to your backside when you screwed up. That's WHY.
Loading Drills with the SMLE were practiced over and over again to an almost fanatical degree. The proper loading of chargers was one of the first basics that was taught. The proper loading as described is down-up-down-up-down. Down being with the head of the cartridge against the metal of the charger, up being with the rim of the cartridge ahead of the down cartridge.
Chargers also make a lot of difference. The blued chargers are smoother, and load much better than the phosphated ones. Even then, for speed loading, that is not good enough. We spent hours choosing chargers for loading, and then lightly filing the inside of them and polishing the file marks out with emery cloth. And those chargers did make a big difference. My personal best was 39 rounds fired in one minute, with 38 hits and one just off the scoring area by one inch, on a Figure 11 target at 50 yards.
There is also a speed technique for loading. Put the first charger in the bridge, wrap your fingers around the bottom of the magazine, push down FIRMLY with the thumb near the charger,(Leverage). Pull the empty charger out and drop it, (throwing it is an extra time wasting motion,) while reaching for the next full charger, which you will have laid out nicely on a piece of canvas so that you do not get dirt on it. Load the second charger as above but leave it in the bridge. Reach for the bolt while shouldering the SMLE, and push the bolt forward which will kick the charger out of the bridge and load the cartridge.
While the books you mention are good, get yourself a copy of "Shoot to Live." by Johnson. This was one of the best books on using the Lee Enfield, and was the standard Canadian manual during WWII. You find them occasionally at gun shows, but you can also download a copy if you go the the Knowledge Library at --Milsurps.com. If you are serious about shooting the Lee Enfield or SMLE, you NEED a copy.
The angled method of loading cartridges, / / / / / with rim ahead of rim DOES work, but you have to look at each charger when you load it and align it properly. However, the original intent of the Lee Enfield system was MILITARY applications, and if you are standing there trying to load an empty rifle while the Hun with his bayonet is advancing toward you, then you want something that works every time!
It should only take you a year or so of practice to achieve a 30 round per minute rate of ACCURATE close range fire.
.