When to stop tracking that missed shot?

John Y Cannuck

RichPoorMan<br>Super Moderator
Moderating Team
Rating - 100%
15   0   0
My one and only deer so far this year went down something like this.
It was a very cold morning, and had snowed overnight. I headed out with the knowledge that any plan on my sitting all morning was doomed to failure. Too damned cold. So i planned to sit for an hour, then walk for a bit, and sit for another hour.

Forward to 10:00am. I'm at the spot I was aiming to get to. a 50 foot cliff overlooking two beaver dams, about a half mile from my vehicle.
I've been there for an hour, but it has warmed a bit. Never the less, my bladder is complaining, and I stand for relief. Completing that task, with my back to the stiff breeze, I turn to see a doe clearly outlined against the snow, across the beaver dams on the next bump of the ridge.
It was one of those 'oh f--ck' moments, because I knew that the drag out would be epic.
Anyway, I took the shot, or rather I squeezed the trigger.... click.
Waiting a few moments, I ejected the cartridge. The deer was gone, so I peered at the primer. Not much of a dent, Damn, I didn't get all the water out after moose camp rainy season.
But then the deer reappeared, and I tried again, this time with a bang.
But a branch drifted down from the trees, and the doe bounded away tail down. Followed by an unseen fawn, and a fairly decent buck from what I could make out over the rocks below.
Grumbling to myself, I made my way slipping and sliding down the ridge, and across the two beaver dams to where the doe had been standing.
There were her tracks, so while waiting a bit, I dug out my GPS and checked. 314 feet. Should have been an easy hit, but no blood.
I followed and found where she had kicked in the after burners. No blood.
I followed further, she bagan to walk. Hmmm I guess it didn't scare her much, she only ran three bounds. Another 50 feet, and a spot where she stumbled, still no blood.
This is weird!
A few feet more and I see here laying head up, looking the other way. I ended her quickly with a head shot.

Analysis:
Shot hit too far back, clipped the diaphragm, blew a few small organs to bits, and then exploded the paunch.
Messiest deer I ever gutted. OMG mess.

Both entry and exit were plugged with fat. Although she was broadside at the shot, it still hit too far back, and the bullet went on a tangent inside, exiting behind the entry, not across from it. I blame the branch for that.
The entrance, and exit were more of a slice than a round hole.

The drag:
12:30 I was still dragging that deer, along the far side of the beaver pond, in hopes that the guys would soon be along to help. They were, and the last hundred yards were easier with three on the ropes. Up the cliff was using my Jeep, and a collection of ropes and straps.
Length of drag .54 miles. Uphill 200feet. Through a recently selective logged area, nice whippy beeches, tree tops and raspberry cane, punctuated with spears left by the beaver for the unwary to fall on.

Deer were scarce in our area this year, and when I left, I was holding the top of the list in the local buck and doe draw, with one day to go. The doe only weighed 117.5lbs.

Rifle: scoped 88 Winchester, cartridge: 308W, Bullet: 165 Hornady Interlock
 
shot_from_here.jpg

Took the shot from here

found_her_bed_on_the_way_out.jpg

Found her bed on the way out.
 
I'm rarely thinking about the drag when I finally see a deer. I was about 2 miles down this overgrown cutline in the morning, lots of deadfall and creek crossings, and I see a nice buck through the binos, lasered at 1200 yards further.

It only occurred to me later in the day that if I'd shot it, I might not have made it out by dark :)
 
Good for you for finding that deer. I missed 2 of them yesterday. I found no blood and no sign of a hit. There wasn't much of a trail to follow on mine as they headed into thick brush. I gotta practice more and take my time on the shots.
 
Congrats on the Doe, and Kudo's to you for tracking what appeared to be a "missed" deer. An extra hour searching is far better than a lingering death and wasted meat.
 
Great job.... I shot a deer 3 years back thatall I could find off of him was some hair where he was standing when I shot him... I followed his trail for twenty minutes through brambles and thickets until I came on a hawthorne bush that had a big hunk of tallow and four on it....

I looked 25 yards up the traila nd there he was laying dead with a blood trail between the hawthorne and the deer that looked like someone ran through teh bush with an open can of paint spilling along the way... I know what you mean about plugged...lol... and yeah... drag is no object to me either... I have actually halved my deer in the bush, marked it on teh GPS and brought them out one half at a time....
 
Good for you for finding that deer. I missed 2 of them yesterday. I found no blood and no sign of a hit. There wasn't much of a trail to follow on mine as they headed into thick brush. I gotta practice more and take my time on the shots.

Yep.

It is very important that hunters do not take shots they cannot make. Only practice will tell you what you can actually expect from yourself and your equipment. Two misses in one day is not good, especially since no sign of a hit does not prove it was a miss. I hope they were.
 
If a deer doesn't normally high tail it out, with the flag flying, something is up.

Deer don't usually shake, stumble, stop walking after a few jumps, mule kick, leave their tails down, etc etc, if they are not hit.

And not all shots bleed buckets. Some barely bleed at all. And a high heart hit, may leave little blood due to the height of the bullet whole compared to the chest cavity and the lack of blood pumping when the heart is destroyed. And it still might run 75 yards.

Good job tracking and gettin the job done.
 
Good for you for finding that deer. I missed 2 of them yesterday. I found no blood and no sign of a hit. There wasn't much of a trail to follow on mine as they headed into thick brush. I gotta practice more and take my time on the shots.

First time I went out, I was taught a very valuable lesson, and it really helped me lose the "buck fever twitch" that causes so many missed or wounding shots.

Sit & wait for your deer. When it shows up, put your scope on it, and wait. Keep waiting, don't take the crosshairs off the kill zone. Keep waiting some more. Take deep breaths, relax and enjoy watching the animal through your scope. If you want to "tease" yourself, put your finger on the trigger very lightly and "fondle" it. Keep waiting some more yet. When the animal has left and you no longer have a shot, you're "cured".

Yes, it will "cost" you a deer that day(but I think the Karma Gods will repay you quite handsomely later on in life). And that will sting for a while (I never did get a deer that year due to weather moving in). But every time after that when you have one in the crosshairs, you will know you have the patience to wait until the shot is "perfect" (and you will know what the perfect shot looks like) and that you've also had the self control let one go before. Knowing when NOT to shoot is far more critical than anything else if you want to be a good hunter.

It's a ####ty lesson to force upon yourself, but I think it's a great one. It's what my Uncle did for me on my very first hunt, and I'll never forget the adrenaline rush and how twitchy the scope was that first time. Every time since, it has been steady as a rock, and I've known I have far more time to take the shot than most would expect.
 
I have been blessed in that I have had 5 decades+ of living in prime game country, and have had the opportunity to hunt extensively.
Needless to say, my family and I have enjoyed a lot of prime table fare from game.
I have learned some valuable lessons over the years.
First Lesson: Any unusual movement after the shot almost invariably indicates a hit.
Follow-up is imperative under such circumstances, but a short wait is in order first.
Note: The lack of a blood trail does not necessarily indicate a miss.
Another lesson: Do not take low-percentage shots unless the game is already wounded.
I always cringe when I hear about those who "always" shoot their deer in the head or neck, regardless of distance. Sooner or later, this will lead to loss of a fine game animal.
It is better to let an animal walk than wound and lose it to a slow painful demise.
Third Lesson: Do not take extended range shots unless:
-You know the trajectory of your load right out past where you will be shooting. [This means by actual shooting of targets, not figures from a book]
-You have ranged the animal and know the exact distance.
-Conditions allow for a longer shot. [wind?, Steady rest?, light conditions?, etc]
-You are capable of staying on the vital area of the game animal at that distance.
-If the animal moves off after the shot, you will be able to follow up properly.
Following a few simple principles will lead to fewer losses, disappointments and reduce the criticism of our noble sport.
Kudus to those who managed to find the animal because they persisted.
Have a great hunting season!! Eagleye
 
I have been blessed in that I have had 5 decades+ of living in prime game country, and have had the opportunity to hunt extensively.
Needless to say, my family and I have enjoyed a lot of prime table fare from game.
I have learned some valuable lessons over the years.
First Lesson: Any unusual movement after the shot almost invariably indicates a hit.
Follow-up is imperative under such circumstances, but a short wait is in order first.
Note: The lack of a blood trail does not necessarily indicate a miss.
Another lesson: Do not take low-percentage shots unless the game is already wounded.
I always cringe when I hear about those who "always" shoot their deer in the head or neck, regardless of distance. Sooner or later, this will lead to loss of a fine game animal.
It is better to let an animal walk than wound and lose it to a slow painful demise.Third Lesson: Do not take extended range shots unless:
-You know the trajectory of your load right out past where you will be shooting. [This means by actual shooting of targets, not figures from a book]-You have ranged the animal and know the exact distance.
-Conditions allow for a longer shot. [wind?, Steady rest?, light conditions?, etc]
-You are capable of staying on the vital area of the game animal at that distance.
-If the animal moves off after the shot, you will be able to follow up properly.
Following a few simple principles will lead to fewer losses, disappointments and reduce the criticism of our noble sport.
Kudus to those who managed to find the animal because they persisted.
Have a great hunting season!! Eagleye

So true.... +1.... practice practice practice
 
Also - bigger calibers usually give a nice-sounding 'thwop' when they connect, smaller calibers don't always. A big round-nose bullet at a moderate velocity and a nice soft lead core makes for a very distinctive sound when it connects.
 
This is the first deer in a very long time that did not drop at the shot for me. Experience trailing deer "missed" by others is what makes me follow up every shot, including those of the others I hunt with.
At our usual ranges, less than 50 yards, a 'miss' is quite often a hit.
I hope the new hunters reading this thread will take the hint, and follow up.
 
First time I went out, I was taught a very valuable lesson, and it really helped me lose the "buck fever twitch" that causes so many missed or wounding shots.

Sit & wait for your deer. When it shows up, put your scope on it, and wait. Keep waiting, don't take the crosshairs off the kill zone. Keep waiting some more. Take deep breaths, relax and enjoy watching the animal through your scope. If you want to "tease" yourself, put your finger on the trigger very lightly and "fondle" it. Keep waiting some more yet. When the animal has left and you no longer have a shot, you're "cured".

Yes, it will "cost" you a deer that day(but I think the Karma Gods will repay you quite handsomely later on in life). And that will sting for a while (I never did get a deer that year due to weather moving in). But every time after that when you have one in the crosshairs, you will know you have the patience to wait until the shot is "perfect" (and you will know what the perfect shot looks like) and that you've also had the self control let one go before. Knowing when NOT to shoot is far more critical than anything else if you want to be a good hunter.

It's a s**tty lesson to force upon yourself, but I think it's a great one. It's what my Uncle did for me on my very first hunt, and I'll never forget the adrenaline rush and how twitchy the scope was that first time. Every time since, it has been steady as a rock, and I've known I have far more time to take the shot than most would expect.

:D

I watched had a buck in my scope for a good 2 min this season, it was too small and the rack was messed 3x1 I could of shot him so many times Finally I let him see me behind the tree and he stopped and just looked at me. I could of shot him again a few dozen times. It wasn't till I stepped out from behind the tree I was using for concealment that he figured it out :D and took off.

Who says camo don't work. (I wear WW2 Norwegian army wool pants and a Brit cammo smock, and a green fleece watch cap)
 
:D

I watched had a buck in my scope for a good 2 min this season, it was too small and the rack was messed 3x1 I could of shot him so many times Finally I let him see me behind the tree and he stopped and just looked at me. I could of shot him again a few dozen times. It wasn't till I stepped out from behind the tree I was using for concealment that he figured it out :D and took off.

Who says camo don't work. (I wear WW2 Norwegian army wool pants and a Brit cammo smock, and a green fleece watch cap)

If you're standing behind a tree, what makes you think the cammo had any effect at all? I was sitting on a hillside glassing earlier this season when a mule buck walked out into the open less than 100 yards away. I watched him as he followed the doe he was trailing for several minutes. At his closest, he was less than 60 yards away. I was sitting on a log, in the open, on the side of a hill wearing the red coveralls and my blaze orange hat mandated for years in Sask. He never did realize I was there. Are red coveralls great cammo?

Nope, it was sitting very still and his state of mind (horny) that made me invisible. Cammo is made to fool hunters, not deer.
 
We had a lrg WT does go 1/4 mile with one lung exploded.Along with the diaphragm through the paunch exiting the flank.Shot with a 6.5x55 at 75 ft during a drive.Bled all over when pushed ,quit if left alone with no snow for tracking.Found her ready to bolt behind a brush pile at 10 ft.One more between the lookers with my .250 The right lung was gone hit dead center with a 130gr Scirrocco II Harold
 
Last edited:
If you're standing behind a tree, what makes you think the cammo had any effect at all? I was sitting on a hillside glassing earlier this season when a mule buck walked out into the open less than 100 yards away. I watched him as he followed the doe he was trailing for several minutes. At his closest, he was less than 60 yards away. I was sitting on a log, in the open, on the side of a hill wearing the red coveralls and my blaze orange hat mandated for years in Sask. He never did realize I was there. Are red coveralls great cammo?

Nope, it was sitting very still and his state of mind (horny) that made me invisible. Cammo is made to fool hunters, not deer.

tree was 6" round and I'm +40" round :D and I was only 30yds from the deer
 
Back
Top Bottom