AG42 vs Hakim vs SAFN49 vs SVT 40

I had owned an AG42 (traded it about a month ago for a NO1MK3 enfield). Anyhow, it was fun to shoot, loud, accurate, but watch your fingers. It makes the garand thumb look like a walk in the park. Very easy to field strip, I could do it in about 15 seconds. A pain to recover the brass. I was going to do the gas mod to it but ended up trading it. It's also funny when your friend is videoing you from the side and gets beat up by the gas escaping from the porting.

Another problem that I had with it was that in my area I couldn't find factory ammo cheap. The 5 closet gunshops that I frequent had limited quantities of it (under 5 boxes at each place) but it cost anywhere from $30 to $40 a box. Those prices are not so bad in a bolt or single shot, but in a semi, with the tendancy to want to keep on going until the bolt locks back, not good.

I reload, so not as big a deal, as long as I can find my brass. Definitely would need to add a gas system if I went this route.

That being said, in a couple of years I might just get another.

I have wanted an SVT40 going on a year now, but I just can't justify getting one yet. I know this will probably bite me in the a$$ latter, but I am too devoted to my beloved enfields. It (the SVT) uses the same tiliting bolt as the AG, it has the adjustable gas system, robust and it should always work. It too might be a little heavy but heavy is good, heavy is reliable. If it doesn't work you can always hit them with it.

Oddly enough I seem to remember the SVT weighing less than my hakim, and apparently the AG42 is similar in weight to the hakim? There's certainly a lot more wood and metal on them. I quite like the 7.62x54r round, but that darn fluted cylinder just chews brass up... that's actually why I sold mine... drove me nuts with it's destroying of reloadable brass. Surplus is all well and good if you like cleaning dirty corrosive crud out of the gas system, but once it runs out, you're back to destroying brass :( If there weren't fluted chambers I'd be on the SVT like a fat kid on a donut.

As for 7.62x54r, I can't see the supply drying up. The surplus might run out but there will always be new manufacture (CZ/Seller&Bellot, MFS to name a couple) for a few dollars more. (Hey there is another movie reference;))

All that being said, I would snatch any of them up if they crossed my path and the price was right.

I have the AG42,Hakim,FN49 and SVT40.

AG42, very good rifle,simple, accurate,no recoil and 6.5x55 is sweet.

Hakim, same as AG 42 but adjustable gas system, i only fired fews rounds with it. Its very heavy and loud as hell.

FN49 egyptian contract, i didnt have time to fire it yet. Very high quality rifle,excellent sight system,easy to take down,adjustable gas.

SVT 40, still my favorite:D In good hand, very reliable,adjustable gas system, not so difficult to field strip and clean,accurate,well balanced,i love the 7.62x54R. I have the scoped version too but didt'n have time to test yet. Somes said the sniper 1 is not really good others said that is not that bad. I guess that mount and individual rifle can vary on the result, i hope to try my SVT sniper soon to see how is it.:)
Jocelyn

I do like the fact that after market scope mounts are made for the SVT that uses the milled rails on any model. Might not be the most accurate, but hey, if it's minute of pie plate I'll be ok.

The SAFN is heavier in the hand than the rest, but I have to admit it's still one of my favorites. The SVT has a fragile frigger mechanism, both the Hakim and AG will blow crap into your face at times, and now that someone has mentioned the MAS 49....what a horrible odd piece - heavy, ungainly, wierd ergonomics and an unusable sight in anything but bright light.
I have owned several selections of each rifle - 6 SAFN's, 3 Hakim's, 3 AG's, 2 SVT's but only 1 MAS49, as the selection in Canada is pretty sparse.

Speaking of blowing cr@p in your face - what about the AG42 Kabooms from using low burn rate powder and having a premature bolt unlock and cartridge failure in the action? Since I reload that's something of a concern, since I'm dicking with the loadings, and commercial ammo has a tendency to be low pressure slow burning to cater to some of the older guns.
 
I do like the fact that after market scope mounts are made for the SVT that uses the milled rails on any model. Might not be the most accurate, but hey, if it's minute of pie plate I'll be ok.



Speaking of blowing cr@p in your face - what about the AG42 Kabooms from using low burn rate powder and having a premature bolt unlock and cartridge failure in the action? Since I reload that's something of a concern, since I'm dicking with the loadings, and commercial ammo has a tendency to be low pressure slow burning to cater to some of the older guns.

Reloading smart is the key here....ESPECIALLY with an autoloader.
 
I've read that for reloading the AG you want to use a medium burn rate powder, and you'll be fine. Also if you had mentioned that if you got an AG you would be doing the gas block mod; again you would be fine b/c you would be able to adjust that to your loads.


When firing a Hakim, keep your mouth shut.

Gun gases taste horrible...

AG42 as well. But a least they taste nothing like the gases from corrosive milsurp 7.62x39. Bip.
 
But a least they taste nothing like the gases from corrosive milsurp 7.62x39. Bip.

I know that's a shot at me. You're just insanely jealous because my milsurp semi-automatic has never failed. And rounds are cheap like borscht and I don't have to travel through the 7 circles of hell to find it.

With regard to the topic at hand, I'd be biased toward the SVT40 or the SAFN 49, mostly because I'm not pleased with the AG42 personally and the Hakim doesn't really turn my crank.
 
AG42B swede

I have owned the swede and the 49, sold the 49 and still have two of the swede AG42B. One is all original LNIB the other came with mods, so it now has the gas adjustment plug and a scope mounted on the bolt cover. The cover had work done to it so it has no free play sideways or verticle, yet still can do what's required. This rifle shoots great, and will compete with the Garand , 49 or any of the rest.
Enjoy. Bill
 
Back
Top Bottom