Free Norinco!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Technically according to Chemist's OP of "...4417th person to post in this thread." the winner is post #4418 since he is 1st, add 4417.

No, because he is not discluding himself from the tally.

He is the first, but that is included in the wording that the 4417th person to post will win, not the 4417th person after him.
 
Replace "4417th person" with "1st person", does that mean he wins or post #2.
No, because he is not discluding himself from the tally.

He is the first, but that is included in the wording that the 4417th person to post will win, not the 4417th person after him.
 
If you wanted to play technicalities it says nothing about 4417th post, it was 4417th PERSON, that would leave us a long ways off if you only counted each usename once.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom