Don't confuse things necessarily. Even if ATT's were a condition on your license, so that clubs didn't have to apply for them for you (in Ontario at least), does NOT mean that clubs would not make you take their club level safety course. Unless you are discipline specific (like an IPSC, IDPA, PPC, Cowboy match), it is unlikely a club would let you just walk in, site unseen, pay your dues, and start shooting your handgun. If you are unsafe and send a round over the berm, the whole club is shut down. The main purpose, I think for have ATT's being a condition on your license is to prevent the need for "all the other ATT's" other than the long term on. Like for a gunsmith, or to pickup at a store, or to go to the boarder etc.. An RPAL, and an ATT automatically issued (like in Alberta I believe) does NOT mean you can shoot safely, the club is still going to want to be sure they can trust you not to get them closed down.