I have 2 Mesas on my 2 590A1's and I think the tac star plastic one is just as good and cheaper. I have yet to try out the Velcro side saddles, but the price and ability to hold extra shells as well as rip off and add a new saddle intrigues me.
I am of the same mindset.
I have the tacstar and is very consistent in terms of it's ability to hold the shell. They don't bind when dirty or gritty and are not sensitive to cold weather like some reports I have read about the Mesa rubber bits. Price wise, you really cannot argue.
For myself, I searched for along time for a local vendor for the Elastic carriers. They offer so much more per dollar than anything else. Some of the newer gen velcro carriers have a plastic saddle now but it still adds weight to the receiver.
Light weight, adds little to no discernible weight shift to your firearm (until you load it up)
Collapse in on themselves when removing lowering it's profile
Flexible mounting options, anywhere you can stick the velcro, you can add some shells
Repeatable and reliable shell retention
And the most important part: price, these things are very cheap.
I made this video some time ago while I was testing the shell retention (I admit I missed quite a few shots, but I wanted to test it hard) I am at the end anchoring the line
[youtube]iXF-I3GfwI0[/youtube]
I had 4 on the forend and a 6 shell on the side.
Nothing fell out
