Douglas,
Sorry to hear of your bad hunting experience...95% of all PH / Outfitters do run a ethical, honest and good outfits. Yes, there are the BAD apples and you have to be wary of them...We cannot compare RSA and Namibia to the Zimbawian's or Zambians, but both Namibia and RSA do cater for Plains Game and Big 5 hunts - FIRST TIMERS and EXPERIENCED hunters.
Hunting was NEVER and will NEVER be guaranteed unless it is canned...Hunting The Kimberley's and Namibian are different hunting to the THICK JESSE (bush) of the RSA Limpopo / North West / KZN areas, and the more open you environment the bigger your farm will be, it goes hand-in hand the field carrying capacity...Farms in RSA where hunting is conducted varies from 500ha to 25 000ha (private land).
Some pointers to look at:
1. Have a hunting contract in place before the safaris commence!!! (all pro's / con's / exclusive / included / payments, must be indicated)
2. Have your PH / Outfitter send your previous hunting references!!!
3. 'Shop around', there are very good / honest outfits out there!!!
Bushwacker............you obviously do not know this site yet and are very new, I have hunted every region in SA and taken virtually every trophy available there. I have hunted every region of Zim and taken virtually every trophy available there. I taken elephant in Bots, hunted Zambia, Namibia and Congo. I'm pretty sure I know "the thick stuff", in fact I would say the Congo is thicker than anything I've seen in SA and I've hunted the eastern cape. I have really only hunted with one outfit with any real problems, I do my home work and due diligence, and generally hunt with some of the oldest and best southern Africa has to offer.........I assume you know Coenraad Veermaak, PH license #1 in SA, Johann Carlitz, who owns virtually every elephant permit in Botswana and the Stormberg Elangeni group consortium.
All I was saying to the OP is be aware and ask the right questions, even the oldest and biggest in Southern Africa are struggling for our disposable income these days and these "little" add on expenses are becoming all too common, with all the operators. It has nothing to do with the ethics of the hunt etc, but they all think we are filthy rich and what's another 500 bucks to us, or a thousand. My son found out the TRUE cost of an African hunt a couple of years back and is still paying for it. He was not deceived in any way he just refused to listen to the old man about all the other costs involved..........air travel of course, but airport transfer charge, hotels, oh ya and then there was the extra animals "you can pay us when you get home program", staff and PH tips, more hotels and meals, dipping packing and shipping of trophies and finally the importation costs and taxidermy costs. He now knows the true cost of an African adventure and won't be going back anytime soon.