I was commenting on overall length, not black powder or the .30-30 cartridge.
Was just pickin'... No worries
I was commenting on overall length, not black powder or the .30-30 cartridge.
I always liked the .270/160gr KKSP CIL used to make available to reloaders.They were great for jumping bedded deer and would penetrate them lengthways if need be.............Harold
A 20" 270Win loaded with a heavy RN bullets (if they still make them) at reasonable velocity with a low powered variable scope would be as good as any other chambering out there for close up use.Why use a flat shooting "long range" cartridge like .270 for a bush gun?
You would have high exit pressure and lots of muzzle blast probably more recoil than a 308. It doesnt make sense to me and accuracy would be degraded by the short sight radius especially elevation for open sights. Their is not enough bore volume in a short barrel for a 270 of course it would work but i wouldnt own it. Also you would have less horsepower than ashort barrel 308
A 20" 270Win loaded with a heavy RN bullets (if they still make them) at reasonable velocity with a low powered variable scope would be as good as any other chambering out there for close up use.
Most of use have a bunch of rifles in various chamberings laying around for different situations, but if someone wanted to keep it simple, two guns in 270 would work just fine.
Right, but neither would work better than a 270 loaded and set up as I described.ONE .308 or .30/06 would work just fine...
Right, but neither would work better than a 270 loaded and set up as I described.
For a man with a small arsenal... two rifles in the same caliber is... well, boring!
Gatehouse said:It seems to me that you are willing to go to quite a bit of work to avoid a bit of extra reloading. The rifle you describe will work fine but so will lots of other options without the extra work.

i didnt want to answer affirmative to your origional question if you were a total idiot and whether it made any sense. still not saying your a total idiot but it doesnt make sense to buy a new gun wrong caliber for what you want for the advantage of not having to reload another calibre. pluss you have to modify the gun. for the amount of shooting you describe you would not have to reload at allThanks for telling me a bunch of stuff I already know.
How much "horsepower" and sight radius do I need for 50 yard shots?
I am more interested in a light weight, short, easy to handle gun. I already have a scoped tac driver for open fields, and sitting in a tree stand.
Where I live (Huron county) I am unable to use a center fire rifle to hunt deer....I must use a shotgun and use the new rifled barrel slugs.For a bush gun it would be hard pressed not to use a pump shotgun. I have shot deer out to 300 yards and killed them deader then dead can be (lol)...these new slugs have came along way..
Oh reeeeeeeeeeally?Most hunting bullets just explode upon impact.
Some expert Twilight Zone opinion, right there.Some will be sent into the Twilight Zone.




























