I just did some testing today with 168 HDY BTHP (I still have a few hundred left to shoot).
Did tests at 200Y with a bipod and a bag, nothing super fancy about minimizing group size, relaxed regular shooting to test velocity and average groups.
43.0 H4895, no crimp, same headstamp cases, measured to a relaxed +- .02 grains (plus the scale error of .02 itself)
Test 1: .020 off lands (2.914 really long COAL).
AV 2775, ES 27, SD 9 Group size: 1.4 MOA, and if you add the flyers it's 1.8MOA, so strange thing is that it had more consistent velocity but shot poorly.
Test 2: 2.800 std COAL
AV 2807, ES33, SD13 Group size: .8 MOA, no flyers. More variation in velocity but much tighter group.
I got some stiffer extraction with the highest velocity shots, so I'm probably at max with 43.
So I think that I will keep at at STD COAL because it seems to shoot well, and I'll load tune from 42.0 to 43.0 and see how it works.
Opinions?