I've owned both 11-87 Guns in the 3 inch and Super Mag 3-1/2 inch, And I can tell you from experience that the 3 inch model is the way to go. The Super Mag needed really heavy loads to function reliably and light 2-3/4 inch loads were out of the question. Even in the standard version, a smooth bore deer barrel with rifle sights needs heavier loads to cycle as anything under about 26 inches won't cycle the lighter loads reliably in these guns. For a tactical build, go with an 11-87 3 inch with a deer barrel & rifle sights, remove the detents from the mag tube and put a 1 shot extention on it. You can do lots if other mods like pistol grip stocks, railed fore ends, etc.
IMHO, I see no benefit to having a 3-1/2 inch tactical gun, as you are sacrificing mag capacity and severe recoil for very little return. If you're heart is set on a 3-1/2 inch, then I would go with the new Versa-Max-the Super Mag's replacement. There are not a whole lot of aftermarket accessories available for this yet but they will slowly start to become available as the gun becomes more popular.