17HMR blew in half!

wayupnorth

CGN Ultra frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
8   0   0
Location
Northern Alberta
My dad had a 17HMR round split right in half today, jammed up in the gun too, had to use a dowel to push it out.
ive never seen a rimfire have a failure like this before!

8BD26021-E936-4B4A-AAFF-CD1AF54D5FB3_zpsxx1znx7p.jpg
 
I had one box where 3 or 4 brass split from the mouth down to the shoulder and a couple others here and there, but never that bad. Also had one squib from another box and the bullet was stuck a few inches from the muzzle. All Hornady 17 gr vmax in a Marlin 917v.
 
Win ammo and a savage will do that 7 times out of 10 in my experience. Sold my savage a few years ago and bought a cz never had any cases split from any ammo except remington as I haven't tried it because its around $5 more a box.
 
I bet Winchester ammo... we had a few batches of Winchester ammo split at the neck and blow out just like that one... never happened with CCI or Hornady.
 
Winchester 17HMR ammo~bought 2 boxes...never should have bought any. Lots of cases splitting, but never as bad as that. The VERY odd Hornady case MIGHT have a very small crack at the shoulder, but it's not common at all. Granted, I don't tend to inspect spent rimfire cases unless something strange is happening.
 
Had the same thing happen in a Sako quad, sent the rifle away for inspection, and got winchester involved. Win (0lin)replace the remaining ammo and the rifle was fine. Bad lot of Win ammo.
 
I get some split necks in my CZ 452 Varmint with Hornady sometimes, and had one Winchester pulled out with a small screwdriver. 1st and last box ever. I have had split unfired Hornady necks as well!!
 
Split necks on .17HMR is a common thing no matter the gun or ammo, do a little google search on it, or do some reading over on rimfire central. The shelf life of .17HMR ammo is low compared to other ammo don't quote me but think I saw 5-6 years, and storage environment a bit more important. The case is primed before it is swedged down and therefore cannot be annealed so is prone to stress crack over time, watch for date of manufacture when you buy, and only stock what you will shoot in a couple or so years.

Also a warning to all, when shooting be very cautious of a misfire a guy I know had some real bad ammo once CCI in this case, the necks had split and then I suspect damp storage he had a few duds in some boxes. Well long story short, when they went click and you would eject it the lead would stay in the chamber, he was at the range with his kid and the first bad one went click, the kid ejected it saw it had no lead thought she just forgot to cycle it and loaded another and bang.

At the time they didn't even realize what happened just knew the mag plate was bent after the loud bang and the gun now had a lead stuck in it, brought it to me to fix, I got the lead out only one in there and fixed the mag plate, took it to the range with his ammo and test fired it, worked fine so sighted it in then had a misfire went bolt up then back down, click again, ejected and lead wasn't there it was stuck in the chamber, the casing still full of powder and good primer hits. I looked at the rest of the unfired ammo and found avg 11 split necks per box of 50, in 4 boxes, mystery of what happened to the gun when him and his kid were at the range solved and my guess is as told above.
 
Back
Top Bottom