I've been lusting after a Hornet caliber single shot for a long time.
Some pertinent gleanings that I have gathered together include that the real problems that came from the Hornet that gave it a horrible rep, center around the huge variations and differences in the chamber specs and the cartridge specs in dimensions.
The Winchester 43's and the Savage 340's seem to be reputed to be some of the worst offenders.
Not helped by the locking, IIRC, all taking place at the bolt handle, allowing some movement and wear issues.
The two problems caused, were that the cartridges rarely sat in the same positions, causing the case to sometimes swell off to one side, crooked, and that the cartridge case was worked way too much if the shooter was reloading with regular dies, which pushed the brass back to "standard" cartridge size.
Lee collet dies are supposed to be "the" answer, or at least one of them. Fireform the brass to the chamber, and then avoid working it as much as possible.
If that Win 43 were mine, I'd not be too keen to pound out the chamber for the sake of a few feet per second. Not without trying the collet die route first, and seeing if that gives the improved case life.
I just got a regular Hornet reamer in the mail. Slowly gathering stuff together. If I happen across a 17 cal barrel, I may try to track down a 17 AH reamer, but for now it looks like a 22 H is in my future. If that does not satisfy, maybe I'll punch it out to a K, but from what I have read, the regular Hornet offers as much as I figure I need from it, and case life should be really good, if I can keep the chamber and the dies pretty close in size, and to heck with the SAAMI (SAAMMI?) specs that are so far apart in size.
Saw a write-up online about an outfit that was making Hornet barrels for Contenders, out of .223 bore 10/22 take-off barrels, and having no pressure issues with the jacketed bullets. I'm going to have to have a close look at the size of that pilot.
The rimfire twist rate of 1:16, would mean light bullets only, but what the hey, it's not like I'd be going out for the 1000 yard shoots with it.
Edit: Hmmmm. Odd. Tried the reamer in 4 different rimfire barrels. No chance of sliding in on two of them, one was feeling like it might go but would be too tight, and the pilot slid right in, on the barrel that was once part of an Anshutz Biathalon gun. Kinda makes sense, as the rifling in that barrel is visibly shallower than the others. Maybe a guy has to look at a removable pilot conversion on that reamer.
Anyways. Sorry for the side-track!
If the K Hornet is what you figure you want, then it's what you need, eh!
Cheers
Trev