I recently purchased this Browning M1885 from "Doug", who has recently become my "Overbore" Rifle supplier, the previous rifle being a Rem 700 in 300 RUM. I don't "need"it, (I only hunt whitetails at 200 yds and less - no Pronghorn at 500 yds), but I wanted it. Before there'a a chorus of "It's overbore!", "It's inefficient", and "It's a barrel-burner", let me say - "obviously". I can afford the powder, and if, after hunting with it for 40 years, the barrel has lost its accuracy edge, maybe my grandkids will re-barrel it.
Below: Browning M1885 "High-Wall". 26" fluted 1:10 twist barrel. Bushnell 3200 5-15X50 scope in Leupold rings
Below L to R: 25/06, 257 Weatherby, 257 STW
Below L to R: inverted bullet showing throat length, seated 100 gr Sierra Game King at 3.540", unseated bullet.
I wanted to zero the rifle, and try out some powders, so I chose 10 different powders, of which three are obsolete (H570, H5010 and H870). All loads are published maxes, or if no info was available, what I believed would be under a max load. Now that the rifle is zeroed, I have some nice fire-formed neck-sizeable brass and some load data, I'll choose a bullet (100gr TSX?) and do some load development.
In doing the load development, I also learned a bit about a few powders for which there is very little data, i.e. their relative burn rates in the 257 STW. Here it is:
Winchester 7mm STW brass sized to 257 STW
CCI Mag Primers
3.540" OAL (0.060" off the rifling)
1. Re25 - 84.0 grs - 3800 fps (max load)
2. H570 - 86.0 grs - 3575 fps (well under max load)
3. H1000 - 86.0 grs - 3880 fps (max load)
4. Retumbo - 88.0 grs - 3850 fps (max load)
5. H5010 - 92.0 grs (full) - 3850 fps (just under max load)
6. H870 - 92.0 grs - 3850 fps (just under max load)
7. Re50 - 92.0 grs - 3650 fps (well under max load)
8. H50BMG - 92.0 grs - 3540 fps (well under max load)
9. US869 - 92.0 grs - 3550 fps (well under max load)
10. 20N29 - 93.0 grs (full) - 3540 fps (well under max load)
I'm done with H570, H5010 and H870, as they are obsolete and I only have 1-2 lbs of each. My beloved H870, and H5010 would probably have been excellent choices, but alas, they're gone forever.
I'll likely settle on Retumbo, Re50 and H50BMG for the next stage of load development.
If the definition of "Overbore" is that no powder exists that allows the use of a full case and not be overpressure with heavy bullets, then the 257 STW is certainly not overbore. 100 grs is only a medium weight bullet, but Re50, H50BMG and 20N29, would still be under max pressure with a full case with a 120gr bullet. Interestingly, US869, even though having a burn rate between H50BMG and 20N29, is so dense (I could fit 102.0 grs in the case under the 100 gr Sierra), that I could go no more than approximately 96% load density.
I image that 20N41 would be a good powder choice, as would Re33 when it comes out.
Below: Browning M1885 "High-Wall". 26" fluted 1:10 twist barrel. Bushnell 3200 5-15X50 scope in Leupold rings

Below L to R: 25/06, 257 Weatherby, 257 STW

Below L to R: inverted bullet showing throat length, seated 100 gr Sierra Game King at 3.540", unseated bullet.

I wanted to zero the rifle, and try out some powders, so I chose 10 different powders, of which three are obsolete (H570, H5010 and H870). All loads are published maxes, or if no info was available, what I believed would be under a max load. Now that the rifle is zeroed, I have some nice fire-formed neck-sizeable brass and some load data, I'll choose a bullet (100gr TSX?) and do some load development.
In doing the load development, I also learned a bit about a few powders for which there is very little data, i.e. their relative burn rates in the 257 STW. Here it is:
Winchester 7mm STW brass sized to 257 STW
CCI Mag Primers
3.540" OAL (0.060" off the rifling)
1. Re25 - 84.0 grs - 3800 fps (max load)
2. H570 - 86.0 grs - 3575 fps (well under max load)
3. H1000 - 86.0 grs - 3880 fps (max load)
4. Retumbo - 88.0 grs - 3850 fps (max load)
5. H5010 - 92.0 grs (full) - 3850 fps (just under max load)
6. H870 - 92.0 grs - 3850 fps (just under max load)
7. Re50 - 92.0 grs - 3650 fps (well under max load)
8. H50BMG - 92.0 grs - 3540 fps (well under max load)
9. US869 - 92.0 grs - 3550 fps (well under max load)
10. 20N29 - 93.0 grs (full) - 3540 fps (well under max load)
I'm done with H570, H5010 and H870, as they are obsolete and I only have 1-2 lbs of each. My beloved H870, and H5010 would probably have been excellent choices, but alas, they're gone forever.
I'll likely settle on Retumbo, Re50 and H50BMG for the next stage of load development.
If the definition of "Overbore" is that no powder exists that allows the use of a full case and not be overpressure with heavy bullets, then the 257 STW is certainly not overbore. 100 grs is only a medium weight bullet, but Re50, H50BMG and 20N29, would still be under max pressure with a full case with a 120gr bullet. Interestingly, US869, even though having a burn rate between H50BMG and 20N29, is so dense (I could fit 102.0 grs in the case under the 100 gr Sierra), that I could go no more than approximately 96% load density.
I image that 20N41 would be a good powder choice, as would Re33 when it comes out.
Last edited: