I have not researched why some powders "bark" more than others is short barrels. But it does not seem to be just an issue of powder speed (muzzle pressure).
I have suspected that it might be what happens with muzzle gasses. Rifle powder does not provide enough oxygen to burn all the combustibles, so these hot gases can ignite when they hit the air, making a flash and bark.
But if you try two or three powders as part of your usual velocity/accuracy investigation, it should be obvious if one is quieter than the others.
I have a 17" 308 carbine that is absolutely brutal with some powders.
I have suspected that it might be what happens with muzzle gasses. Rifle powder does not provide enough oxygen to burn all the combustibles, so these hot gases can ignite when they hit the air, making a flash and bark.
But if you try two or three powders as part of your usual velocity/accuracy investigation, it should be obvious if one is quieter than the others.
I have a 17" 308 carbine that is absolutely brutal with some powders.
Last edited: