powder burner said:
I thought I would stir up some controversy. Which would you pick as a lightweight rifle, and why? (include which rifle brand) Lets say you are using it for mostly deer sized game out to 300 yards. Whether you reload or not, factor that into your answer.
I think we'll get some interesting answers
Dear Powder Burner
I would pick the Remngton 700 Mountain DM in .30-06 Springfield..
Box Mag Capacity: 4
Barrel Length: 22"
Twist: 1:10"
OAL: 42 1/2"
Weight: 6 5/8lbs
I have owned this rifle in .260 remington and loved it
My only two concerns were
1. Diversity of animals I was comfortable shooting with the .260 rem
2. The rifle has no open sights
I love the Remington Detachable Mag
I think a DM is important for when you need a quick load straight out of the truck (which happens) rather than single feed. This allows you to keep your eye on the animal(s) and load 4 rounds right now. I believe any hunting rifle should have a detachable magazine for that reason alone.
The .260 remington is the sister of the 6.5X55 swedish mauser although the later slightly out performs the .260 Rem (but not by much).
I believe the .30-06 is the better hunting calibre as it is much more diversified as to reloading and factory ammo combinations. If you want bone crunching performance then you can easily manage 180gr to 200gr ammunition while not sacrificing too much on long range performance (up to 400m).
I shot a 5-round 22" at 1048 yards using factory 180gr winchester ammunition out of my stainless Winchester Model 70. Dosen't sound too impressive but at that range I'm suprised I even hit the paper consistently. Sure the .260 could have done the same but bullet performance and penetration would have been seriously retarded.
Remember that a light bullet moving at lightening speed is not always preferable when hunting. A slower moving heavy projectile that does not entirely exit allows all of that energy to be absorbed by the animal. This is what made the 170gr FP .30-30 Winchester so famous inside of a 150 yards. The .30-06 will give you similar performance out to and exceeding 400 metres.
I understand that you identified deer as the target animal, however should you find that moose on a frosty morn shouldn't you be running the calibre and combination that will do the job for both?
Good Luck in your search Buddy.