I made the decision last fall to try and "standardize" on a calibre for hunting with my son. I didn't want us to not be able to hand each other a cartridge if needed quickly, and have to worry about different cal's. Guess what I settled on?
three-oh-eight...oh yah'.
I live and hunt in South Africa, and have owned and used all the non-magnum calibers as well as .375 H&H. Had reason to lean out my number of rifles and what have I kept?
Here is the list:
** My 24" barrel sub-MOA Musgrave Vrystaat model .308W (the 30-06 went to my younger son, the BRNO ZKK 601 in .308W went to my elder son and the .270, .243 and .375H&H were sold).
** Walther .22 Hornet (the Musgrave Ambidex .22LR went to my elder son and the 90 year old Slazenger .22 LR to the younger who still flattens tiny turkey silhouettes with its open sights at 50 yds)
** The Gamba Ugertechea ss box lock 12g bird gun which has taken 1000's of high power No. 4's and 7's and still locks as solid as the first day. All the Purdey ancestry is there. The Winchester Mod 1300 was sold).
** The Taurus .22 LR wheel gun which takes beer cans at 50 yds as if it has been doing it for 30 years which it has. (The .44 Rem Mag and 9mm Browning HP were sold).
** The very light, iron sight sporterised Lee Enfield .303 British for warthog and Kudu in the very dense bush where a scope is a hindrance.
On the .308W: From Eland at 80 yds in the bush down to Springbok at 250 yds on the plains to head-shot culling of blesbok at 200 yds, the .308W has not once needed more than single shot.
I still have to meet the African large antelope that knows the difference of being killed by a 6.5x57 or a 7x57 or a .308W or a 30-06 Spr or a 8x57 or a .303 or any of the .30 magnums. The latter simply mince more good meet, but the former kill as smartly, only neater. I have hunted them all with all calibers except the sub .375 Magnums, but saw the results of the little magnums and was never impressed. There is only one magnum calibre which impressed me and that is the .375H&H.
So why did I keep the .308W and not the "more versatile" 30-06?
The .308W is a tack driver and is versatile enough - and I need not hunt Cape Buffalo anymore. The only Cape Buffalo I took in my life was with the 30-06 and a strong bullet of 220 gr (which is too long and heavy for the 51mm case of the .308W). It went about 50 yds and died.
I see absolutely NO use for the small magnums, and neither do my ears like them.