I found 869 to be to slow burning for the "relatively" lighter bullets (under 300gn). I shoot the 265gn Barnes LRX with H4831SC and have great results. In my testing of 300, 265, and 250 grain bullets, I found that as you go lighter in the bullets, you go faster in the powder burn rate. Being US869 is one of the slowest burning powders, it's not surprising it's not that accurate with 250gn bullets. For me with 300gn sierras, H1000 works best. Of course, enter disclaimer here, your results may vary.
Cheers