Yes you are right, but the original 44 gamegetter was .427 round ball
215 grains with a charge of 34 grain of blackpowder that is the load I was inquiring about. I am not equip to reload 44-40 so I was asking other members if they did it or knew a place that sell it.
I was even thinking of buying .44 plastic cup for reloading shotshell and using it instead of 410 guage if the chamber is to tight. I have to ask first.
A 45-70 sized round ball of lead (.458) is only about 170 grains.
What I'm saying is you'd best check your sources, something is amiss.
I'm not familiar with the rifle, or cartridge at all, but I do reload 44-40. 215 grains was one of the standard bullets for it. As was the 200, and the 205
A 200 grain .427 bullet:
Note, a round ball of the size .427 will not weigh even 200 grains
Dies for the 44-40, in the original Lee hammer operated kit are incredibly cheap, and require no high cost extras to produce usable ammunition.
All you need to add are the components themselves.
You can then load a 427 round ball, whatever it weighs, or load a conical, and get some accuracy
Sadly, I no longer see 44-40 in the listings for these sets on the website, however, they do exist. Probably wouldn't take too many gun shows to fins one. or even here on our EE.
Nothing stopping you from going into reloading on the cheap. Lee's hand press kit is also inexpensive, and will allow you to branch out into other reloading if you get the bug, and most gunnuts do.
It's available from many of the site sponsors.