45 COLT blackhawk loads in a 94 lever

machinistbutler

CGN frequent flyer
Rating - 100%
23   0   0
Location
Edmonton
My friend has a blackhawk recently purchased as well as a 94 trapper in the same caliber.He has heard that they both can take the same pressures.I know the blackhawk is tough and even has its own reloading section is some manuals,how does the 94 compare,I imagine it would be stronger than the old colt handguns..
 
I think the Ruger may actually be a bit more robust than the '94.

For my own use, I shoot a 300 grain Hornady XTP in a Trapper with a near-max load of Winchester 296. It's about a grain or two less than the top load for the Ruger Blackhawk, but it's been good to shoot in the little carbine. They are quite accurate and seem to hit with a pile of authority.

I've had three '94's in .45 Colt over the years and have found that their chambers seem a fair bit looser than the Blackhawk. That's consistent with what John Linebaugh wrote about the '94's and may be one of the reasons to avoid going too hot in the carbine.

You may want to do a google search for .45 Colt loads in rifles - there's lots of info out there.

Check:
http://www.realguns.com/archives/119.htm

and especially this one:
http://www.linebaughcustom.com/Default.aspx?tabid=114

John Linebaugh has done a pile of work with the heavy-loaded .45 Colt. I would take a careful look at what he has to say.

In part:
Another trend I have seen lately is the loading up of the new Rifles being chambered for the .45 Colt. Namely the Winchester 94 angle eject. The same writers that are now loading the rifles to a before unheard of pressure level of 40,000 CUP in this caliber are the same ones that belittle and talk down the .45 Colt in a sixgun. Does the weak case that limits the Sixguns abilities suddenly transform into a magical wonderall of magnum strength when chambered in one of these lever action wonders. I find their investigation of the facts at hand less than complete. I have rebarreled a few 94s in .45 Colt that had chambers so oversize than factory ammo would split cases and separate heads upon the first firing. Factory ammo is loaded to around 13,000 CUP even though the industry standard is 15,900 CUP. Personally I prefer shooting my heavy loads in well made sixguns rather than the current trend of rifles out there chambered in .45 Colt.
(my emphasis)
 
There is a good article on heavy .45 colt load in lever guns at:

http://www.leverguns.com

I have developed loads with 300gr rnfp gas checked bullets for my M-94 and Blackhawks with H 110 and W 296 that work pretty good (1750 fps 20" rifle and 1375 fps 5.5" revolver IIRC). I want to try the 94 on deer and black bear but have yet to have the opportunity, hopefully next year. And yes I beleive the Rugers are stronger than the 94, but have had no pressure problems with my loads.
 
Back
Top Bottom