The type of gun the ammo is to be used in will have some bearing on OAL.
For example, the 1911 types have a magazine which permits a longer length than the BHP types, so ammo for the former can be loaded using more powder and yet maintain acceptable pressure levels if seated out for a longer OAL.
This the same principal which IPSC shooters apply to 40's built on a 1911, S*I or PARA frame. Ammo used in these applications will not chamber in a Beretta for example
In any application go for the longest OAL which will, fit the mag, feed and chamber. OAL under this criteria will vary with bullet type and ogive.