A Sad State of Affairs

leonardj

CGN Regular
Rating - 98.2%
54   1   0
Location
Ontario
A note to the moderators: The forums alluded to below does not include CGN.
I did however, consider that the message should be made available to the airgun enthusiasts who may frequent this forum, so that they could be made aware of what has been happening within the Canadian airgun community for some time now, in hopes that it will assist them in making better informed decisions before shelling out their hard earned cash.
If this post violates any CGN rules, I apologize, and will understand if it is removed.



Yes indeed, it is a sad state of affairs within our Canadian airgun community when opportunistic profiteers seem to be running the show, and those with actual airgun knowledge and experience, accrued over several decades, are browbeaten, insulted, or have had ficticious allegations made against them on public forums, in an attempt to tarnish their character and ethics. I can think of several very knowledgeable individuals in just the past few years that had simply given up in frustration with trying to contribute anything worthwhile to the various forums. As a result, many people new to the hobby are often receiving bad information, which ultimately results in financial loss to them, which can be very discouraging to say the least.

The worst part of the whole situation, is that many of these opportunistic profiteers seem to be able to get away with some utterly despicable business ethics, by threatening those whom they have cheated with being banned from a forum, or forums, which the victim frequents, through either real, or implied influence with the foum(s) owners or administrators. Sadly, despite my repeated attempts to convince many individuals into “outing” these disreputable profiteers, no-one yet has been willing to stand up to this unjust intimidation. All have chosen to simply accept their own financial loss, and “let others learn for themselves”. Apparently most people are content with this skewed “status quo”.

I’m sure that a few of my detractors will happily point out that when many of the guns that are damaged as a result of bad advice, or improperly executed repairs by some of these opportunists are brought to me for rectification, that I am also making some money through my services. I don’t deny that I charge for my services, but quite Frankly, I would just as soon that I did not have to clean up someone else’s mess, at further expense to the owner. A couple of these “opportunists” have even gone as far as to suggest that I should correct their improprieties for free, while they continue to charge outrageous sums to basically bugger up people’s guns. Brilliant.

The following are just a couple recent examples of the disgraceful business ethics alluded to above. The descriptions of the guns are purposely vague to protect the owners.


A very nice, virtually brand new, German made spring gun was sent to me, which could no longer be cocked or fired. While I was trying to establish how the failure occurred, the owner admitted to me that his gun had been “lube tuned” by someone that was recommended to him as being a “reputable” tuner. What I found upon opening the gun up, was that in my opinion, the gun had never been apart, so I had to assume that the “tune” was in fact, a “spray-in lube tune”. Further questioning the owner confirmed this – he was told to “let the gun sit for a few days for the lube carrier to evaporate”, before trying to shoot it. When he finally did shoot the gun, it was detonating badly. He contacted the tuner, whose advice was, “just keep shooting it until you burn off the excess lube”. The owner followed the tuner’s instructions, but after about “30 or 40” shots, still detonating loudly, the gun could no longer be cocked. The owner again contacted the tuner, who at this point, told the owner very impolitely, that he was just being problematic, and that no further communication could be expected.

The owner eventually found his way to me. Upon opening up the gun, it was painfully obvious that this was not going to be an inexpensive repair. The severe detonation had resulted in the mainspring being shattered into several pieces, and also had several fractures that had not quite broken all the way through. The spring guide was also broken into a number of pieces. The piston seal, as expected, was badly burned, and in need of replacement. Some debris from the badly broken mainspring had gotten trapped between the piston and the compression chamber and caused some nasty scoring. The repair parts alone total almost $100.00. Needless to say, the owner was very upset, and felt that the tuner should pay for at least a portion of the repair cost, but his attempt at contacting the tuner was met with threats and intimidation. Thus, the owner of the gun absorbed both the cost of the “tune”, as well as the cost to repair the damage resulting from that “tune”.


Next up, we have a CO2 gun, which was in need of a re-seal. The owner was directed to a “reputable” repair person who proceeded to “fix” the gun. However, it would appear that the repair person only replaced the easy to get at seals, and left the difficult to change seals in place. The gun held, and the repair was paid for. As one would expect, it did not take long for one of the seals that was not replaced to fail, and when the gun was returned to the original repair person, the owner was turned away – the repair person didn’t have the time to determine why the “resealed” gun was leaking once more.

Once again, the owner eventually found his way to me. Upon disassembling the gun, I found that the previous repair person didn’t even take the time to clean the various parts – he just put the new seals onto dirty parts and shoved it all back together. Of course, as I began to remove the difficult to remove seals, was when I realized what had happened. I made the owner aware of what I had found, and encouraged him to post his experience, and I would even supply him with the pics of the proof of what had been done. The owner contacted the original repair person, whose only response to being confronted about his unethical behaviour, was to threaten and intimidate the owner, who immediately backed down, and simply absorbed the cost of the original “repair”, as well as the added cost of having the “repair” fixed properly. The owner ended up paying over twice what I would normally charge for a re-seal of this gun.


These are not just a couple of isolated incidences, they are becoming all too commonplace.
People selling guns or accessories with known (to them) defects as being “in perfect working order”, modder or repair wannabes charging people for doing more damage than good to their guns, “airgun expert” posers offering bad advice to new people in the hobby. And what is truly disappointing in my opinion, is that these individuals will continue to do so with no fear of repercussion, because their many victims are intimidated into compliance of not making their bad experiences public.

Given just the number of such improprieties that I know of, and I highly suspect that there are a great many more that we are not aware of, I find it incomprehensible that the Canadian airgun community, and especially the many who have been victimized as noted above, continue to accept the current “status quo”.
 
I suppose some could just learn to fix their own gear. The times that I have,,, have been pretty enjoyable, and if something fails, at least you have a working knowlege of the unit. Theres lots of helpful info out on the web. U
 
Last edited:
I suppose some could just learn to fix their own gear. The times that I have,,, have been pretty enjoyable, and if somethjng fails, at least you have a working knowlege of the unit. Theres lots of helpful info out on the web. U
I agree that fixing your own guns can be an enjoyable aspect of the hobby.
Unfortunately, those that choose to learn by working on the property of others, and at other's expense, is flat out wrong and unethical.

There is absolutely no safeguard in place to keep anyone, regardless of competence level, from posting all sorts of nosensical, badly thought out info on the internet.
When I read or view some of this info, which in some cases is so utterly ridiculous, I have found myself wondering if the info was posted out of malice just for some hack to get his jollies knowing that some poor SOB will ruin his gun as a result.
 
Last edited:
Some may fake knowledge, but eventually it will catch up to them and bite them in the butt !
Sadly, it is usually not the person faking knowledge that gets bit in the butt - it is usually the hapless individual that was seeking assistance, whether in the form of advice, or actual repairs, that gets bitten.
What should have been a $50.00 or less repair, can become a $250.00+ catastrophy after the wrong person has been into it.
 
It is difficult to find competent air gunsmiths, more so than gunsmiths because there are fewer of them. Not everyone has the technical ability, tools or time to learn how to fix their own airguns. When I needed work done resealing some old Crosmans, I was fortunate in being directed to leonardj by a member on one of the airgun forums. I recommend leonardj to anyone needing work done on their airguns.

Yesterday, I needed to make an appointment with my doctor, couldn't remember the telephone number so Googled her. Much to my surprise there was a website rating doctors; fortunately, my doctor had an excellent rating. Perhaps there should be a forum on gunnutz where people can rate air gunsmiths and gunsmiths.
 
I just noticed there is a place to recommend gunsmiths under the Gunsmithing forum. Hopefully, people will also recommend those working on airguns.

Great idea to have an "air gunsmithing" component. There is a small supply of these people in Canada.
 
Great idea to have an "air gunsmithing" component. There is a small supply of these people in Canada.
What is unfortunate, is that a lot of folks that have managed to successfully bolt a few aftermarket parts onto their Crosman 22xx series guns, now consider themselves an "airgunsmith", and will start soliciting work on the various forums. Fact is, most of these guys will end up using these guns to learn on, and if they screw up, and more times than not they do, the owner is on the hook for the cost of the "learnng experience" and the repairs that are now needed on top of the original problem.

I've been at it for around 40 years, and have been into quite literally hundreds of airguns, dating from 1868 to current models, and I still run into the occasional gun that has me scratching my head for a bit.
 
So leonardj. What do you think of the nitrogen piston rifles that are being sold these days?
I'm not sure exactly what you are looking for here.
If you are inquiring about internals, can't tell you - never been into one, since these newer guns are supported by their retail and warranty people. I just don't get involved with them.
The only potential concern with the Nitro-Piston could be the cost of repair if the nitro-piston should begin to leak. No idea how the replacement cost of a new nitro-piston unit would compare to a conventional mainspring.
 
Len - I clearly recall some of your earlier efforts to deal with this problem. In particular, your posts that included photo's of what you were encountering were highly instructive (this was, of course, when you were posting ...'over there';))

That you continue to encounter the work of those butchers is a shame, to say the least.

Anyways...thanks for continuing to post on the subject. Might well save some poor guy a good deal of money...and frustration.

Cheers - Gus:D
 
The only potential concern with the Nitro-Piston could be the cost of repair if the nitro-piston should begin to leak. No idea how the replacement cost of a new nitro-piston unit would compare to a conventional mainspring.

About 60% more expensive as far as crosman repair kits go, not too bad. I've heard some Theoben gas ram that's been in use since they were invented (and one cocked for months) and still in perfect working order, so they should last quite well.
 
About 60% more expensive as far as crosman repair kits go, not too bad. I've heard some Theoben gas ram that's been in use since they were invented (and one cocked for months) and still in perfect working order, so they should last quite well.

Correct me if I am wrong; I believe many of the Theobens have a valve built into them for adjusting the pressure, thus they can top them up if needed over time. Those Brits like to stay *just* under 12 ftlbs.
 
the nitro springs I believe are just die springs. usually warranted by reputable manufacturers for 1000000 strokes(Dadco,Kaller,etc). I think they are around 75-100 dollars. yes they are pressure adjustable, but you would need a nitrogen cylinder and regulator and fill fitting to adjust up or down. I looked in the dadco catalog and found some springs that would work I believe, but would need the specs on a comparable wire spring(OD, stroke and spring rate per .100").
 
I agree that fixing your own guns can be an enjoyable aspect of the hobby.
Unfortunately, those that choose to learn by working on the property of others, and at other's expense, is flat out wrong and unethical.

.

Any plumber, carpenter, electrician, welder , mechanic etc learned their trade on someone else's equipment and on someone else's dime. That's the way the world works. It's on the job training. It is up to the customer to make sure they chose a reputable business to deal with.

It is not ethical for someone to mislead a customer or knowingly get in over their head though.
 
Any plumber, carpenter, electrician, welder , mechanic etc learned their trade on someone else's equipment and on someone else's dime. That's the way the world works. It's on the job training. It is up to the customer to make sure they chose a reputable business to deal with.

It is not ethical for someone to mislead a customer or knowingly get in over their head though.
Any of the trades that you note usually involve the serving of an apprenticeship by the person learning the trade, and while, as you note, they are learnng on the property of others while serving their apprenticeship, they are usually doing so under some degree of supervision by an already licenced tradesperson. Businesses also generally carry insurance, that will protect both the customer, and the business in the event of an unexpected major screw up.

This is not the case with those that hang out their "airgunsmith" shingle, and start soliciting repairs.
There is no defined criteria or testing for competency, nor is there licencing of any sort.

IMO, charging someone to do half a job, or for all practical purposes, bugger up a gun worse than it was when it was brought to them, definitely qualifies as "unethical".
The mere fact that, as my original post points out, a few of these individuals have to resort to threats and intimidation of dissatisfied clientele, says a lot about the individuals involved.
 
I had one of the Theoben FAC rifles. It came with a pump, plain old air, I guess that is mostly nitro...

There was a screw at the back of the gun and when it was pulled out, a "bike" pump would attach to it. Then you pumped it up. There was a ring of tubing in the pump, so that it could not fully compress the air, and that was the 12 ft lbs limit. To go beyond that, you had to remove the ring.

I don't believe I ever FACed my gun. Those british guns are normally built to shoot best at the 12 ft lbs level, and while they are more powerful when FACd it can throw a lot of the engineering out of the door.

Theoben break barrels are still pretty much my favourite guns ever. BUT, they had the worst trigger of any gun I have ever shot. I guess it was high quality, but it was the least manageable I have ever used. That gun with an HW trigger would have been perfect.
 
Great idea to have an "air gunsmithing" component. There is a small supply of these people in Canada.

You could just take it to a real gun smith.... The only thing is it might cost more to fix then it's worth to replace some firearms are that way as well so it depends on what you want.

I know 1 gunsmith has the abilty to make new springs if he can't order them it just takes time to make something so it costs money because his time is worth money... It all depends on what you want.

Air guns are allot like real firearms in many ways. They work in similar ways the big difference is they have a seal in them and sometimes valves that can wear out or break.

I like the break action pellet guns because they're super simple and if you want to pump them up to a higher speed just compress the spring with some washers and now it's a firearm speed or buy one that is faster for a couple 100 bucks.. You can even add desil fuel to the pellets on spring guns and they fire faster and hit harder it's just dangerous to do that so..
 
Back
Top Bottom