Tholo is where I went for the plains game portion of my hunt. I hemmed and hawed about it before I booked, because I was a bit put off by the idea of hunting on a private fenced property for "captive" animals. But...the property itself is almost 300,000 acres...that's more than 450 square miles...and they also manage and have access to another 1million+ acres of land for hunting. You might see the occasional cattle fence when on the property, which is not even an inconvenience to game animals, but the exterior fence? You'll see it when you enter and when you leave, that's it. It never felt like anything resembling a "canned" hunt. The family that operates it has all the bugs worked out, they know what they are doing and they know how to provide the experience you want.
As an example, the owner had a large seacan that was extensively modified into a walk-in gun vault. I oohed and aahed over the assortment of fine firearms in there when I went in to select a shotgun for the day of wingshooting I did. The guns were available for client use, and I wanted to use my own rifle for hunting...but there was some tempting stuff in there...
Having said that...as unbelievably satisfying as that part of the hunt was, I'd have to say that overall I preferred the buff hunt I did on a conservancy in Namibia's Caprivi Strip. Probably saw less than 10% as many game animals, ran into some "unsavory" characters a couple times, visited a couple of native villages to collect intel, stayed in a classic tented camp (as opposed to Tholo's stone cottages), heard lions roar most evenings, rode in a mokoro dugout canoe in a crocodile-infested river, spent days hiking in ankle-deep up to crotch-deep flooded grassland, nearly got stuck in between the toes of a hippo we surprised at close range, and generally felt like I was in true wild Africa for every second of the week I spent there. Incredible experience.
Tholo felt like a luxury resort in the Muskokas, from which we drove each day to various nearby areas for hunting. If I were to go back to Africa with my wife or granddaughter, Tholo is absolutely where I'd head.
The Caprivi felt like a camp in a remote part of Alaska or the NWT (but with somebody to cook terrific meals and also do my laundry...); if I were alone again as I was for my safari, I would much prefer that experience.
At Tholo, you absolutely get to taste everything you shoot, if you want to...and, man, did I want to! My first meal when I arrived on the first day was mutton. Mutton!

I commented on it and was told that I could have or could avoid anything I wanted.

They were quite proud of the quality of their beef, but I wouldn't know; we ate game that I had shot for every main course during my entire stay. At its worst (warthog, zebra) it was good; most of it, especially eland and gemsbok, was absolutely superb.
In the Caprivi, the meat technically belonged to the inhabitants of a couple of villages located nearby. They of course allowed us to take all we wanted for a cookout that night. Biting into a perfectly-prepared rare steak from the buffalo that had inhabited my imagination for almost a half-century previous was practically a religious experience for me.

That was the only animal I shot during my week there. I had several opportunities to take others, including a sable and a waterbuck which were both very hard to pass up...but I had my buffalo goggles on and my wallet was getting pretty thin by that point.