Just to give a little more info --
It doesn't feel like a lubrication or grit issue. The shotgun is simply very stiff on opening if the hammer is uncocked (the hammer is cocked by opening). The thing works like normal if the hammer is cocked. So I think there is some mechanical problem specifically to do with the action of cocking the hammer, but I am still able to operate the gun if I give it the significantly extra oomph it requires. On other O/Us you can operate the lever and the shotgun will 'flop' open from the weight of the barrel, this one will open like 15% and stop. I can force it open, and if I do, the cocking sound is much louder than usual.
Consulting the diagram and pictures on the internet (one provided for reference), it looks like everything is in the right place. I'm at a loss. Studying the diagrams and breaking out the bench vice and some magnifying glasses, it looks like the cams and hammers are fine. I even oiled up the springs, thinking that the friction of the springs against the guide rod they ride on might account for the significant extra force required.
I can only really think of a few possibilities:
1) Lots of increased friction on the hammer cocking action -- doesn't seem like this is the case, everything is pretty well lubed
2) Some sort of loss of mechanical advantage is making the cocking action require more force -- I think the answer is in here somewhere, but if the cam is working properly then I can't think of another component that could do this (i mean, the barrel isn't going to get shorter or lighter). I've tried to account for every part on the diagram and I think they're all there. I checked the floor under my table to check for loose parts with a flashlight...
3) Actual increased spring pressure on the hammers -- maybe brushing the springs the first time with an oiled brush I inadvertently increased their force somehow? Like they're tuneable or something?