This is my experience:
I bought 10 .50bmg cases from ATR a few years ago. Advertised as "once fired, lake city, sized, trimmed, ready to reload". $3.50/case plus tax/shipping. Cases came masking taped together in a plain white envelope, three of them had the case mouth crushed almost flat, they all looked like they'd been trimmed on a belt sander, primer pockets were deep enough that the primer sat around .02-.03" below flush, the cases were trimmed about .03-.07" short, 7/10 cases were stamped LS 43 and two were SA 80 and I don't remember the last one .
Maybe there was a miscommunication with what it was I ordered and to be honest, I probably should have called to straighten it out, but for the 40-something I spent, I couldn't be bothered and chalked it up to a learning experience and decided to add ATR to my list of companies I don't do business with.
I'm not implying that ATR/Rick is a bad business/guy or that ATR doesn't put out quality rifles and equipment because it's obvious that there are a lot of happy customers, I'm just not one of them. On the other hand, I bought a Versa-pod from him prior to this and it was alright and came as advertised (although I've discovered I'm not a huge fan of the versa-pod but that's a different topic and not ATR/Rick fault), so *shrugs* maybe it was just a fluke.