well now im super interested!
went back a couple pages and read some posts.
it seems just like any other gun on the forums, 8 guys come in and say good stuff then 1 loud person comes in spitting nails and pissing vinegar.
Pretty much. For some reason, things can get pretty heated about NEA. I have some NEA parts (on my 858 and on my AR), but not a complete NEA gun. All I can say is, the parts I have, have held up well. A close friend has an NEA AR, and he's been quite happy with it.
But that's not exactly a scientific sample.
Honestly, though, if I was buying another AR, I wouldn't strike NEA off the list of potentials. I know they had some problems in the past, when they were first getting into the AR game, but that's not really shocking. It takes time to work the kinks out of a production line, especially when you're starting from scratch. A number of dealers I essentially trust to "not sell crap" carry NEA guns, and to me, that says more than most of the internet chatter you read.
I'm somewhat surprised a few of the haters haven't jumped in. There are a few people here who had bad experiences, and legitimate beefs. But that seems to have gone fairly quiet over the past couple of years. I suspect that whatever problems they've had in the past, they've worked through.
Does that mean you're guaranteed a non-lemon? Heck no. Mass production is what it is, and sometimes a dud will slip through the cracks. It happens even with the best manufacturers. But I believe it's well within reason, now, otherwise non of the dealers would want to carry them. High return rates kill margins for dealers, and none of them want to put up with that.