Asking for guidance/mentoring?

Maybe he didn't "blow you off" at all... maybe he is working a full time job plus three side contracts for 100+ hours/ week... and he has a wife and three kids and volunteer charitable work also... maybe he wanted to give your question his full attention, as he has with so many others on CGN over the years, but is having difficulty finding the time to do so... maybe...


Ok Hoyt! Why did you blow him off? I don't believe you're working 100+ hrs a week either so your excuse better be good!! ;)
 
Have you ever asked for guidance or some mentoring and been shut down from fellow hunters? I recently tried to reach out to one of our own on CGN for some hints or tips for hunting an animal I have never hunted before and was blown off. I was quit shocked that a knowledgeable member here with years of experience hunting what I was looking to get into would not care to share their knowledge and experience.

Anyone ever have a discouraging experience asking for help or are most guys pretty good?
lots of good hunters out there, but few are good teachers, and some are not at all what they claim to be when once you have them out in the woods.
 
Have you ever asked for guidance or some mentoring and been shut down from fellow hunters? I recently tried to reach out to one of our own on CGN for some hints or tips for hunting an animal I have never hunted before and was blown off. I was quit shocked that a knowledgeable member here with years of experience hunting what I was looking to get into would not care to share their knowledge and experience.

Anyone ever have a discouraging experience asking for help or are most guys pretty good?

There are some things you can try that don't require a mentor to accompany you into the bush. The first is to choose a hunting area that will allow you to see some distance in front of you, and allow you to glass the area carefully as you move forward. Ontario is blessed with many lakes, rivers, and hills, and the bush is dotted with swampy areas that are free of trees or willows, allowing the opportunity to see an animal before it becomes aware of you. A canoe allows you the ability to move silently, and again, allows you to see some distance ahead. Working lakes shores, if sandy, will provide tracks, and let you see well ahead. Hunting along power lines and railway right of ways is often productive, in that in addition to providing you with the ability to see well ahead, they are also trails which the animals to traverse with less effort. If you find a high hill which overlooks the land around it, particularly if overlooking an old burn, you can spend a pleasant day waiting for game to appear within rifle range. If you intend to hunt in agricultural areas, fields bordering thick cover can be a good place to observer deer in the morning and evening.

Don't wash with scented soap. Don't wear cologne or after shave, or scented antiperspirant. Don't smoke. Don't wear "noisy" clothing. If hunting with a partner, don't engage in needless chatter. Don't wear anything reflective if you can avoid it. Don't rush, take your time to glass the area ahead of you, and be aware of the wind direction. When it comes time to shoot, if you can get closer - get closer, if you can get lower - get lower, acquire a stable a position as possible to shoot from, and concentrate on the mechanics of making a good shot without thinking about the animal, how great a trophy it will be, or anything else that takes your attention away from making a good shot. Make as good a shot as you can possibly make, as quickly as you can make it, without rushing the shot. If the animal moves off before you shoot, don't panic, wait and see if it stops to look back, if it does you must be ready. If he moves out of sight before you have a chance to shoot, quietly take up the trail, or attempt to move to a place where you can intercept him. At the shot, cycle the action as quickly as you can with the rifle at your shoulder, in preparation for a follow up shot if it proves necessary. Mark the spot where you last saw the game, and mark the spot you shot from, this may make it easier to find the downed animal.
 
Most shooter/hunters will bend over backwards to help an FNG. Some guys are just rectal orifi though.
For hunting Yogi, a big pickle jar filled with bacon drippings/fat and with holes in the lid, hung high in direct sunlight so the fat melts and drips down a tree has been known to attract him. So has day old dough nuts, cake, peanut butter, etc very securely stashed. The really important part is doing all this in a place you can check every day in pre-season scouting.
You'll want to read everything you can find online and in your local library about black bears too. Pay close attention to what needs doing after Yogi in on the ground. Bears are trichinosis carriers and you must care for the carcass properly. No 'dump bears' either.
 
Ok Hoyt! Why did you blow him off? I don't believe you're working 100+ hrs a week either so your excuse better be good!! ;)

My aching old, decrepit body is telling me it is the 100 hr/week schedule over the past three months... and probably for the next three months also.
 
Blasted Saber: Maybe you should keep your over generalizations to yourself and not paint all Western Canadians with the same brush. I don't have a problem with baiting and neither do all of the hunters I know, its just not legal in most of Alberta. The primary reason, as I understand it, has to do with having bears become too comfortable around humans and increasing the threat of bear attacks on campers/tourists - we only have the NATIONAL parks in our primary bear hunting grounds. I have yet to meet a fellow AB hunter advocating for no baiting. If I could bait I know I would.

As you understand it is wrong. The reason we can't bait in many parts in Alberta is due to grizzly bears.

There are still many zones in Alberta where baiting is allowed.

Baiting Black Bears in Alberta
In some parts of Alberta, the use of bait is allowed to attract bears for the purposes of hunting.

Black bear baiting

allows hunters to be more selective in choosing a bear to harvest
creates close-range shot opportunities for a more humane harvest
helps to ensure that females with cubs are not killed
Why Baiting is Allowed in Some Places and Not Others
Baiting for the purposes of black bear hunting is not allowed in areas with resident populations of grizzly bears.

Grizzly bears can be extremely protective of food sources. The hunter or other members of the public that approach a bait area that has been claimed by a grizzly could face a serious conflict if the grizzly defends its food source.
 
Black bears are creatures of habit, but not in the same way as whitetail deer. They do not travel highly predictable routes between bedding areas and food sources. Their movement patterns are primarily dictated by specific food sources and wind direction and thermals. Bears tend to bed in random locations, but those which provide them with safe escape routes and consistent thermals for scenting danger. The idea of baiting is to create a food source that allows some predictability in the bear’s movements… this gives you an edge in getting into position to make a quality shot. In many areas, such as thick boreal forest regions, this is the only realistic method of hunting black bears. Baiting is misunderstood by many who have not done it. The perception is that it is taking unfair advantage and is a slam-dunk method, and akin to shooting fish in a barrel. This could not be further from the truth. In WMU’s where baiting is the primary method of hunting bears, the success rate is in the range of 10-15%... similar to regions where other methods, such as spot & stalk, are utilized. Bears are wary creatures with keen senses, they are well aware that humans are associated with the bait sites, and they approach with extreme wariness. Wind is your best friend or worst enemy, as bears rely most heavily on their sense of smell as their best line of defense.

When positioning bait sites, there are a number of factors that can up the odds of success. The idea is to choose a location that is natural to bear movement, rather than trying to draw them to areas that are convenient for you. The location should have the elements that encourage their frequent and prolonged usage. These elements, in no particular order, are; travel corridor, cover, water source, escape routes and limited human access.

The best tool in positioning your bait site is a good topographical map of 1:50,000 or better scale. If you are searching over a large region as would be the case when hunting large tracts of crown land the standard 1:50,000 map provides sufficient data for choosing the location. When hunting specific tracts of private land, a 1:20.000 scale map will provide greater detail. There are mapping companies that will customize maps with specific scale and allow you to choose the data you would like included.

In searching the map, you are looking for natural bottleneck areas between lakes, or saddles in ridges or corridors between terrain features such as steep, rocky mountains and lakes, rivers or clearings. Bears can and do travel wherever they will, but are most likely to follow natural drainages, particularly following creeks and rivers, where food is more likely and cover is plentiful. Bears are disinclined to expose themselves during daylight hours, which is why they often remain unseen despite living in close proximity to human habitation. Once you locate natural corridors, find those that are also adjacent to a water source with excellent (read; “thick”) cover. The location should also allow the bear to approach and flee in multiple directions… BUT, you will preferably position a terrain feature downwind of the prevailing wind direction, that blocks or discourages approach from that direction, ie. A lake, river or pond, or clearing etc… This will give you a significant advantage when you hunt the location only on the prevailing wind, making it less likely that you will be scented. When I was guiding, I had four to eight hunters in camp any given week, and to accommodate those hunters, I had as many as 40-50 stand locations, this allowed options for each hunter regardless of the wind direction. I did not hunt a quality location on a bad wind, there is no surer way to educate the larger, dominant bears than to have them scent a hunter on stand.

Next you are looking for locations that provide reasonable access to you, but discourage access to others (sometimes only a perceived limitation). Most hunters will follow trails to logical jump off points, and will travel a very limited distance from that point before setting up their bait location. #One of my favorite tactics was to cross a creek or river to access an area. Few hunters will get out of their trucks or off their quads to wade a river to place a bait… but when you find a route that allows easy fording of the river, the opposite bank opens of an area of limited accessibility to humans and a comfort zone for bruins. The one dilemma with this strategy, is that you may (will) loose the location on occasion during high water flooding, but usually only for a day or two until the levels subside. Another, perhaps unexpected, strategy, is to access a good location that is adjacent to a major highway, but does not have a natural stopping location for vehicles to stop… bears can exhibit, secure wilderness behaviours, in these locations because there is little evidence or history of human encroachment. If you are forced to hunt where others are hunting, your “ace in the hole,” is to go deeper and bait better. Lots of quality food, deposited regularly, will dramatically improve your odds of success. I once met a father and son, from Ohio, hunting the same location immediately adjacent to a logging road, on successive days. The father expressed, his disappointment for his excited son, and that he realized that they had been “taken” by a shoddy outfitter, on the adjacent BMA. I had just harvested the final bear of our season and had a number of active baits in the area. I told the father to get dropped off as usual the following evening, and that I would meet them there. The next night, I picked up the pair and brought them into one of my stands being frequented by a nice boar… this required quite a hike, fording a creek and crossing a beaver dam. I told the two to make a careful, patient lung shot and that I would see them before dark, to return them to their pick-up location. I had not reached my truck when I heard the shot, half an hour later I returned, to find an exuberant young man… we tracked the 350 pound boar a mere 50 yards… the bear was dressed and a hauled out, and the very tired, but happy father and son deposited at their pick up location an hour early. The man was flabbergasted that I had helped them, and tried to pay me, but I declined and wished them well. That other outfitter overbooked his lodge, had too few baits, located too close together, too close to human activity and baited with too little bait. He had only five juvenile bears taken for the season, for a success rate of 12.5%... Not counting the mature boar the young man had taken from my stand. On the other hand, we had 23 hunters, 100% success rate on mostly good mature bears and three or four real bruisers… tactics, effort and paying attention to detail does matter. #

Once you have your location chosen, you need to start baiting… ideally you would have started gathering and storing bait months in advance, there was a time when I had a garage full of 30 cubic foot freezers. Start with a strike bait to get scent spread over a large area. For strike baits, I used a large onion bag full of pork fat. Pound a 10” spike high into a tree, hang the bag and then rope it to the tree, so the bears can’t just run off with the whole bag. I never used barrels when baiting, but if you can only bait occasionally or on weekends, then barrel baiting may be your only means of leaving a sufficient food supply to encourage bears to come regularly and stay in the area. I preferred using onion bags and sealed garbage bags for bread stuffs (to keep them moist and fresh)… tied onto the trees the bears would tear out the bottom with their teeth, spilling the bait onto the ground and forcing them to eat a little at the time and move around, at the same time exposing themselves to a patient, careful shot. Use small pieces of bait, so they cannot run off with a large chunk and spend the last few minutes of legal light dining in a thicket, out of sight. Your goal should be to create competition on the bait, multiple bears on a location creates urgency and leads to bears coming in earlier, rather than after dark or legal hunting hours. Keep in mind that juvenile bears are often the first ones in to feed… waiting will often produce a larger bear. Often the boss bear in the area will set-up somewhere in the area and will monitor activity around the bait. The boss bear will charge in to chase off younger bears. We have had baits where as many as eight or ten bears were running each other off and mock fighting for dominance… this has occasionally led to cubs being treed by boars and can get hairy when the tree they choose for refuge is the one the hunter is in, which happened on enough occasions that it was something we coached our clients to deal with. Gather pork and beef scraps, bread, donuts, fruit, vegetables, cereal, grains, dog food etc… Ideally, you will bait regularly and consistently. For volume, I used a full Trapper Nelson rucksack (5-6 gallons) at each bait location, baiting every second day leading up to the hunt and switching to every day once hunters were in camp. Done right, it is grueling, back-breaking work, your legs and lungs are going to burn and you will sleep very soundly each night… at least the nights that you don’t spend on your hands and knees with a Mini-Mag light in your teeth blood-trailing bruins through cedar and cane swaps.

Once our chosen bait locations proved active, we build a Tee-Pee wall set-up with logs spiked at angles on the backside of the bait tree, creating a crib of sorts, which forced the bears to come around the ends, broadside, exposing their vitals to a properly placed lung shot… particularly important for bowhunters, which made up the bulk of our clientele.

Well… OP... that should get you rolling anyway. Good luck.
 
Back
Top Bottom